The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by Phoenix191 pages

bad, bad mental image! 🤪

yep, i'm goin nightmares 4 the rest of my life, and its all because of u.lol

i hope no1 else reads them or they doomed

Dumbledore/Hagrid hehehe

im loving the best tour from another thread

Snape/Harry is completely revolting my opinion. I tend to use the actor from the movies as the mental image of Snape. Which makes it even worst.

Sirius (as a dog) and Harry is another.

Originally posted by impatientinky
sugar&sweet was just talking about another member's (spidergrl) fanfic that's posted here on kmc in the fanfic section. i think so anyway.....🙂

ohhhhh!

Originally posted by Phoenix
Twincest, Sirius/Harry, Dumbledore/Harry, McGonagall/Hermion... the list of minging ships is ENDLESS! ((although I'm just as bad as some people... I like Ron/Draco, which my best mate thinks is foul! 😄))

eww! Ron and Draco!? I always hated it when they made characters look gay. some people think Frodo and Sam from lord of the rings are gay. How could that be if sam got married to a lady? But anyway, getting back to topic, And Dumbledore and Harry sounds really nasty! as a matter of fact, they all sound nasty. I'd be very angry if they made Ron gay. 🙁

I thought Sam and Frodo acted pretty gay to me. They were extremely intimate. Sam was obviously the bottom.

Ron isn't gay. However I like to see some imagination. Any character can be gay. It's just requires intuition and tweaking. Ron and Draco would be just a all-male version of Ginny and Draco. Ya know rich/poor, black/white, cold family/loving family, etc. Those themes would be instilled. Just more sex.

frodo and sam aren't gay. And i don't like fanfictions where the characters are gay. It's pretty gross. 😘

They acted like it. They slept together in the same bed. They were more intimate than most friends were. I'm not saying they were gay, however their actions has made several people ask questions.

Not everyone like the slash fics. However some are very well-written. I read every type of fic. I can't stand the fics where everyone dies a horrible death and Voldemort wins though.

Originally posted by Draco69
They acted like it. They slept together in the same bed. They were more intimate than most friends were. I'm not saying they were gay, however their actions has made several people ask questions.

Not everyone like the slash fics. However some are very well-written. I read every type of fic. I can't stand the fics where everyone dies a horrible death and Voldemort wins though.

Well to bad JRR tolkien isn't around to prove them wrong. 😄

And I can never stand those fanfics either. but I still think the gay fanfictions are gross

y r we still talkin about this? who started this in the first place?

Well someone brought up Ron and Draco as a gay couple, and I thought it was gross. so I replied.

Originally posted by celestial_moon
there r so many threads about this already or similar 2 this

yeah get what you mean.
Why dont we all wait for J.k.R to do her thing and then we'll see whos wrong or right, cause i am willing to wait... 😉

I want it to be Harry/Herminoe

ok for me is the one that harry protects which is Hermione
Ron is for luna and ginyy is for nevilleor draco

ok for me is the one that harry protects which is Hermione
Ron is for luna and ginny is for neville or draco

Oh well, shame that neither are going to get what you want.

It's all a matter of taste really. I detest graphic slash, I think it's truly foul, but gay couples can be really sweet. I'm not suggesting that the characters actually ARE gay, but the point of fanfiction is to explore all the probabilities that the authors can't go into themselves. or example, I thihnk the most interesting fanfictions are the ones that explore the different ways the story COULD end - e.g. what would happen if the fellowship didn't win, what would happen if Frodo had become a wraith when he was stabbed on Weathertop, what would happen if Voldemort won, what would have happened if Sirius actually HAD been Voldemort's henchman... The possibilities in fanfiction are ENDLESS, which is why I like it so much

Well i read a interview about J.K.R and she sadi nobody has gotten the couples right yet, meanong she's gonna surprise us and the interview was before the fifth book came out meaning Harry might go with Luna 😉

I know. I just don't like the idea of a gay Ron. that's all. 🙂