Joseph_Kerr
Senior Member
When FOTR was announced and they had Shore's name listed at the composer, I was highly disappointed and miffed that they did not choose John Williams. John Williams imo is the master composer of our generation and was skeptical of the music.
I bought the FOTR cd the day it came out and listened to it ever day in anticipation of the movie coming out (I even made my crew at work listen to it every night). The music grew on me immediately and the anticipation of opening night was boiling over to see how the music played in the movie.
After listening to both cd's and watching both movies, I think John Williams would have done an excellent Job and capture the movie, but I have noticed lately that Williams repeats certain passages in his movies now. There is nothing wrong with this, after writing so many movies it's bound to happen. Even the great composer Bach stold from his other massses while composing new ones (Bach composed 2 masses per weeks for many years plus raised a family of 17 childrend if I remember right).
I think for these movies there needed to be new blood, and Howard Shore was the correct chose as the composer. He will be forever known as the great composer of The Lord of the Rings Trilogy. 🙂