"Either Must Die in the Hands of the Other". The Lost Prophecy

ahhh don't know about changing you user name........any way Jk said another main charater will be killed didn't she?

what if snape dies by protecting harry...that wud be kewl!

Heh, maybe Voldemort will die? I mean he is a main character...

I just don't know if i could handle any other main character, besides volemort, dying....i'm still in mourning about sirius

Originally posted by iluvorlando
I just don't know if i could handle any other main character, besides volemort, dying....i'm still in mourning about sirius

i agree!

airangel429 makes a good point, but I think it was just Harry's mother's love that protected him from you-know-who. I think the prophecy could be Neville, b/c then the author would be like leading us up to a huge surprise, cause everyone thinks it's Harry Potter 🙂 💃

I doubt Harry will kill Voldemort.

1) The prophecy says so, but JKR would never give us the solution of everything two books before the ending!!!

2) We would have to share the feelings of a future murderer and JKR seems to have a problem with violence according to her statements in interviews and to some hints she put in the books e. g.

- the name of the video game "giga massacre part 3" or so, Dudley (a person every reader hates) throw it out of the window

- Dudley and his gang beating little Mark Evans

- Harry's conversation with Lupin about Sirius deserving the kiss of a Dementor in book 3

- Harry saved Wormtail's life

- the good ones always send the evil to prison but don't kill them

- if you hadn't noticed yet, the persons that have been killed so far were all killed by the total evil, the victims could all be descriped with one word: INNOCENT

(in Sirius's case it's obvious, the only reason of killing Cedric was his presence, he couldn't protect himself, Lily was a young mother and in comparison to James always always on the good side but except the case James also took off Lord Voldemort's underpants he was just a boy that wanted to have fun and never got touched by the evil)

James wasnt the same age as Voldemort I don't think. Voldy was in Hagrid's year, but I don't think Hagrid was In James'. The person you're thinking of is snivellus snape.

Why can't anyone on this forum take things at face value!!!!!!!?

PLus there are several bits. I mean Harry and George beat the crap out of Malfoy, don't they?

erm, voldy got to be at least 66 years old....

thre chamvber was opened fifty years ago and in which year was tom? 6, 7??

and james? how much d'you guess him? 30....something in that area?

JKR said in an interview that Snape's around 35/36 years old (in the Order of the Phoenix), James, Lily and Sirius would have and Lupin and Pettigrew have the same age as Snape. So they're all around 35.

ahhh! thx! 😉

ok i have a theory, if harry's power is suppose to be love and that voldy couldn't stand it when he got inside his head, what would happen if harry's enter's lordy's mind full of emotions???would he be finished? 😕

Originally posted by minnie
airangel429 makes a good point, but I think it was just Harry's mother's love that protected him from you-know-who. I think the prophecy could be Neville, b/c then the author would be like leading us up to a huge surprise, cause everyone thinks it's Harry Potter 🙂 💃

so the last word scar in the 7th book might be there because the scar transfered to Nevilles head 😄
😛

lol! i'll be really dissapointed if it is nevilees prophecy..i mean what a waste of time!

wait some one said something about a Mark Evans? A clue I know it is. Because well why would she say Evans? Plus Harry didn't even know his mothers name was Lily Evans.......

I think he did know his mum's maiden name... It would have been the same as Petunia's...

ok i am really sure lily's last name was evans cause remember in the 5th book when harry was in snapes memory's , he saw his father crossing an L.E. that he had been decorating?? 😍
and about the scar i was just kidding i don't think that it's neville's prophecy but i think that what ever happens to lord v either harry kills him or make him good rather than evil or do one of does things dumbledor said is worse than death to him, the scar would disappear from harry's forhead and the tie would break,

ahhh maybe but back to evans. yes that is her last name but what about mark Evans in the book....ooooand i had a dream the When I read the sixth book sirius came back but i don't remember how....

where does mark come in ? in which book? i don't remember