well i think dumbledore would win
now im a massive lotr fan but just hear me out
gandalf is one of few wizards in middle earth
the story s not based on him being a wizard so he doesnt need to use much magic
dumbledore however is in a story full of wizards and always said to be the best so jk gave him amazing powers that gandlaf just wouldnt need
i have read the silmarillion but here we go hedgemon i pmed this to you cos you showed considerable outrage lol
so here i am to show my true mening of why i chose dumbledore even though i love gandalf sooom much
i meant it as this
dumbledore holds greater power than gandalf because he NEEDS it see the evil in harry potter is voldemort and people have always said dumbledore was stronger so he was given a VAST array of spells in the upcoming book six we get to see him using unthought of spells he advances the avada kedaveda making it shoot out as liquid to kill anything it touches (rumour going about)
gandalf was never said to be as powerful as sauron
gandalf would put up on HELL of a fight but i do believe he would lose
look at the charms dumbledore uses, making things leap to life and save him, gandalf could not do that as it say in simarillion nothing can give new life apart from illuvatar
plus gandalf favours to use his sword alot
given this pm from hedgemon
Re: WHAT!!!
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
sauron wrote on 11-22-2003 12:42 PM:
no i meant it as this
dumbledore holds greater power than gandalf because he NEEDS it see the evil in harry potter is voldemort and people have always said dumbledore was stronger so he was given a VAST array of spells in the upcoming book six we get to see him using unthought of spells he advances the avada kedaveda making it shoot out as liquid to kill anything it touches
gandalf was never said to be as powerful as sauron
gandalf would put up on HELL of a fight but i do believe he would lose
look at the charms dumbledore uses, making things leap to life and save him, gandalf could not do that as it say in simarillion nothing can give new life apart from illuvatar
plus gandalf favours to use his sword alot
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gandalf is a Maia (sp) there is no way Dumbledore could win. Dumbledore has many TRICKS but has he never fought thousands of advancing orcs ready to rip him apart limb from limb. Gandalf never uses his full powers in the books, he's not allowed to. His purpose was to get the people of Middle Earth to fight for themselves. Gandalf is one of the most powerful beings in Middle Earth, he directly defies Sauron, the right hand man of the source of ALL evil. How could he be defeated by a school principle?
i have decided to withdraw my selection of dumbledore and vote gandalf