possible cloned characters

whats a hundred years between jedi's

Well, Mace doesn't get that old. I hope. 😂

I don't think anyone on the Jedi Council has encountered a Sith before. Maybe Yoda when he was younger but the rest haven't met one. It's not a suprise that they can't see what Palpatine is.

Not even Yoda:
"But the Sith are extinct for over a millenia!"
And Yoda is 800 years that is still 200 years before Yoda that the Sith were 'extinct'

Is millenium 100 years?

Tsss!! A millenia is 1000 years

Yoda and the rest of the JC must have been trained by Jedi masters themselves. As the JC are made up from different alien races which i pressume have differing lifespans as well.

If some of their teachers come from long lived races such as Yoda, I assume that these old Jedi masters must have encountered the Sith, before they went extinct.

These old Jedi Masters must have trained the then young Jedi, how to hunt for the Sith or detect the Sith if it were at all possible.

Why? If they think that they are extinct; why bother? Sure, they train with the lightsabre but they didn't fight Sith as part of their training

this is a silly argument, the sith have remained in hiding for over 1000 years because they are very good at hiding!!!!! this inculdes remaining undetected from jedi.

Also i find it amazing that people think ami and pady are different people, did they watch the same film as me??

it is possible that palp is a clone of sidious but very unlikely and i quote "I will make it legal"

ps. someone commented that the scriptment must be wrong cos there is no clones attacking in this film, i think you will find that the big big fight at the end is clones attacking jedi, seems to make sence to me.

My point also R.

it is possible that palp is a clone of sidious but very unlikely and i quote "I will make it legal"

What do you mean by that?

im sorry let me explain, if when the trade federation are told to invade naboo they worry it is illegal and sidious says "i will make it legal", this is a massive hint that he has a lot of political power and infulence ie. he is palpatine. you can just as easily use the quote " i will watch your career with interest" to anakin as proof but i wont lol. I think that generaly the fact that its the same person kinda gives it away lmao.

And how about the fact that the whole film is about how Palpatine uses the Trade Federation to get himself elected Chancellor.

Like I have said before only time will tell whether in fact Sidious and Palpy are clones or whether they are in fact the same person.

But R's argument does nothing to convince either way. Sidious uses palpy as an instrument for his own voice. If palpy is a clone I am sure that he is taking orders from Sidious.

I am not saying that they are clones! I just think this might be a possibility! In a way I am trying to second guess GL. If they were clones, I feel this would make the story more interesting as well as tying in with the whole clone subject running through episodes 2 and 3

Not discounting the possibility of course. But right now we have more reason to think they are simply the same person.

NO!!!! Back to subject!! There is already a topic discussing that; otherwhise this topic will be closed!!

Seemed on subject to me, discussing possible cloned characters. Besides, off-topic topics only get closed if they are over 100 posts.

So who is in the O.T then? Palpatine or Sidious?

And what happens to the other one?

And how did Palpatine/Sidious clone himself when the technology is only being used for the first time in Ep2?

I got this one from Ush: they are the same person, he just dumped the title,
anyway, go to the the topic Sidious or something like that, with the starter Yerssot to get his full explanation

I know they are the same person.

yerssot, I welcome your suggestions, but let the mods decide when a topic is to be closed. And this one is nicely ON topic. Move along.