Ghosts of AOTC

"Hey, you know what? We are heroes, so we must do the journey and get killed so we dissapear!"

That

That would be silly if it was that blatant.

It would be stupid if they said that.

Same thing.

Pfft. Queeq, you will have to do MUCH better than this to beat comments GL has ALREADY made about me being right, the drive of the entire website ands the logical interpretation of events in the films.

Liam Neeson isn;t even confirmed yet, even if he is then it might be as a recording rather than a ghost, and even if he is a ghost we will need to see the circumstances oif that beofre we judge.

Help from an unexpacted corner!! Ush to the rescue!!!!!!!

The film is now in post-production, that means the film-shooting is DONE, Liam is still not comfirmed: that means that he ISN'T going to come back as a ghost, because you need to film his movements for the film.

That's not entirely true now, yersott. They just finished some additional filimg in London. It would have been a peace of cake having Neeson in the studio for an hour or so with nobody knowing.

True enough. Well, we will see...

Yes, we will. 😈

Whats this heroes journey stuff, youre tyring to tell me that in all of the years of Jedi (1000+) not one of them until ob1 completed his heroes journey, c'mon.

Nah, that Hero's Journey stuff is just the basic narratvie structure of the Classic Triolgy (KJ opened up an explaining thread although personally I disloke the concept)

But I agree with your principle- if it was as 'simple' as reaching your destiny, surely it would have happened before?

But SW is not about OB1's journey an destiny. It's about Anakin's and Luke's. So the disappearing thing does not fall into that category.

No, but OB1 is in starwars and he is a jedi. Does it concure to you that Annakin and Yoda are also Jedis?
So the dissapearing DOES fall into that category

personally I disloke the concept

We've only seen 3 Jedi ghosts. That doesn't mean there are only 3.

When I was talking about destiny I think it has something to do with the Prophecy.

ANAKIN: Was created to bring balance. That was his destiny. He did that and became a ghost.

OBI-WAN: I think he was chosen to train Anakin. As Qui-Gon said "Nothing happens by accident" , "our meeting was not a coincidence" and "the force will guide us". I don't think it was an accident that Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon were the ones to find Anakin. Obi-Wan eventually helped him bring balance and was rewarded by becoming a ghost.

YODA: I don't know.

Of course there can be more than 3 ghosts, but they aren't important to the story than

Hhmmm, maybe...

I just don't like the idea of the Hero's Journey, KJ. But I appreciate its presence as one of the theoretical basises for Star Wars.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Hhmmm, maybe...

What of importance was Yaddle for Luke?
Of cource, in 1983 there wasn't even talked about a Yaddle

a babysitter 😎

Let's face it:
GL had to make the PT first and than the rest. Now he has to make an archieval edition to make the link from the PT and the OT even better

Why?