It would depend on which version of the Hulk and which Thor variant. Some Hulk versions (eg Savage and War, especially War) are insanely powerful; while some versions of Thor (eg King Thor) are nigh omnipotent.
But in a 'normal' fight i would have to give it to .....erm ......well,it depends on how quickly Thor can win. If Thor socks it to Hulk quick (before Hulk starts to ruminate on his anger and starts adding to his strength) then the Norsegod wins.
However if the battle progresses for quite some time the match begins to oscillate, before finally starting to turn into a Hulk advantage.
A fight between 'normal' Thor and 'normal' Green Hulk would depend on how fast the battle is. A fast battle goes to Thor, and a slower one belongs to the Hulk.
Let's just say that if you want to defeat the Hulk you'd better do it fast. Real fast.
Originally posted by Euripides
http://www.silver-surfer.us/Top10list/Top10List.htm
Originally posted by spetznaz
That list had one major flaw. It said one of the parameters was the following:
Only superheros allowed. No supervillians or ridiculously cosmic beings of a higher "universal" order (like Galactus, Highfather, Neron or Mephisto) allowed.
Ok, Silver Surfer is not a supervillain, but he is a 'ridiculously cosmic being of a higher order.' He works with the power cosmic from Galactus himself, and he can basically be considered Galactus-lite when it comes to certain capacities.
Also where the heck is the Martian Manhunter? That guy too the whole JLA apart in direct combat.
Anyways, most of the list is kosher. I just wouldn't put Silver Surfer anywhere on that list. Not because he wouldn't win, but because the rules of the list itself disqualifies him.
I guess it is no surprise that the website is a Silver surfer fansite.
MM wasn't on there because he was vulnerable to flame at that time.
Silver Surfer would not qualify as 'ridiculously cosmic being of a higher order.' He's no where near the league of Galactus, Neron, the HighFather or The Living Tribunal. He's qualified for the list.
I think Hulk's always proven to have the advantage in most of their fights..particularly when Thor doesn't have possession of mjolnir....Hulk is someone few can hang with when he gets really enraged..remember he took on the Half the MU(FF, Avengers, Thor and Dr strange) at one point...and they couldn't take him down...I believe Dr Strange ended up banishing him to a dimensional crossroads in order to defeat him...
The hulk has beaten Thor into the ground on NUMEROUS occasions, so its safe to say that the hulk could and will win in an actual battle..
Yeah, thor is a god of thunder(or something like that) but that still won't aid him against raw and growing power incarnate!!(I like that term...power incarnate)so while Thor is trying to summon living lightning to aid him, the hulk would be busy pummeling and pounding the Norse god...
Thor had his hands full with one Gladiator on numerous occasions and needed assistance in order to take down the cosmic being, the hulk on the other hand used "brute strength" to sort of bully kallark from montana to california....(although i smell biasness)....point is..the battle happened and was/is deemed official....
Originally posted by gamewarrior
My mistake Hulks fist is harder than adamantium.
Originally posted by K3VIL
You gotta be kidding me.Hulk was really pissed off when he was able to bend adamantium.But he wasn't able to broke it.The only real way to destroy adamantium is through high level of power, like Odin Force or Power Cosmic or with vibranium of the savage land
Hulk anit got the strenght to break adamantium.