First of all, who are any of you to say what punk is or isn't? Avril Lavigne is not the punk that we all know today. She is a marketing ploy put together by her mangers and she is talentless. Good Charlotte, however, is "punk". Benji loves the music, and he is close friends with Rancid's Tim Armstrong and Lars Frederikson. Benji is a great person and his love for the music is second to none. His brother Joel is only in it for the money, however. They have a new album coming out this year and I'm going to buy it because I've liked Good Charlotte since the beginning.
Now...old punk. Classical punk, I suppose. Sex Pistols are the epitomy of what punk should be. Take no shit, raise hell, etc. I love the Sex Pistols. I also love the Ramones, the Misfits, Adicts, Damned, Buzzcocks, Bad Brains, and all those. I hate the Clash. I can't stand them. But I thank them for giving us Rancid, and I respect what they did.
Newer punk...you can't put it down because it's out future. I love AFI. Old AFI is awesome. Sing The Sorrow is an amazing album, and contrary to popular belief, they did not sell out. They made a decision that was best for them creatively. Rancid is awesome, Propagandhi, Pennywise, Dropkick Murphys, the Business, the Flatliners, No-Cash, Leftover Crack/Choking Victim, Anti-Flag, the Deviates, the Devotchkas...that's real music. The Casualties. That's real music. Punk is the greatest genre ever invented and I for one am not going to tolerate people putting it down.