Didn't you say that you don't like him that much at first but now you think it is a shame he is not back?
Yes, when I first saw TPM I didn't like Qui-Gon. I thought there was no real point to him and it would have been better if there was more Obi-Wan than Qui-Gon in TPM.
But now I think he's one of the best characters and I really want him to come back. It's weird. 😕
I ment that Vader was the best and Luke did take him down. Luke was standing over a defeated Darth Vader and threw away his weapon. Had he held on to his lightsaber I think Luke could have taken down Palpatine, but because of the whole "choosen thing" nonsense we are led to believe that to have been impossible. Either way, Luke bested the "choosen one" and the man who destroyed the Jedi Order, so that makes him the best.
Originally posted by yerssot
and if he defeated his father he would be dark also
Not really. Obi-Wan and Yoda wanted him to confront Vader so killing him wouldn't have made him dark sided, thats just what Palpatine wanted Luke to believe. When Obi-Wan killed Maul he seemed angry and upset, aren't those dark side traits? And he turned out alright.