Is there anybody who didn't like Lord of the Rings:Return of the King

I was a fan of the original Hobbit cartoon movie (1977), and also The
Lord of the Rings cartoon movie (1978). I always wonder what it would be like to see this with live actors. When I heard PJ was goin to do it I was very skeptical, but when I first saw the first scenes of the Fellowship of the ring I was amaze by the beauty it posess. I was delighted to see Tolkien work transform into a movie. I continue to have that feeling in The Two Towers and Return of the King.

So far I've seen that many of you don't find the Return of the King very fascinating. Well, that is your opinion, and I won't be explaining why I liked so much. You didn't like it? Fine! Just don't call it a "waste of time" "overrated" "too much hype" because honestly PJ work his back in order to get this project done! Nearly 7 years of his life were spend working on this film, so that it could provide fans of a new generation the works of Tolkien! You don't like the film? Then don't bother to watch it! Nobody is forcing you to go see it!!

I am not saying he didnt work to make these films. I understand that the films was alot of work. He worked 7 years, so would any director who was making 3 movies. They would probably work around 7 years for three movies
Just because he worked, doesnt mean we cant say it was too much hype. And as overrated, we have every right to say that. If this was another director with another movie, everybody who would love Lord of the Rings and didnt like that movie, they would say that same thing.

i totally argee. the hype with this movie was jsut as bad as the matrix... and the same conclusion

Originally posted by Samas-adian
The answer your question about the story. There was a story but what i mean about Filler, it wasnt good. I felt that Legolas character was horrible. ex. " A diversion" line. I felt no feeling for any of them, I didnt care if they died, lived, or anything. And that the emotion between the character was fake. Thats what I felt.

Yah it was horrible, a mime could be better.
Gandalf was good, Aragon (misspelled i know) was good, Gimli had nothing at all going for him.

they always forget teh short bastards....

i agree with the elephant scene, although it was still pretty cool. but it did lose the LOTR feel and picked up a star crap one.

Whoops 🙄

i don't see how they can make it better, It done for!!! Well it was the best movie since titanic!!! or like 5 years!! End of desscion and it was much less overhyped then matrix. I was overhyped and still loved it, many people were overhyped and came out happy, so if it can do that
means its good.

Moving to LOTR forum.
Moving--moved

why was this moved here??? I loved that movie and all you are dissing it. Thats gonna make some people here mad

I don't think moving this thread here was a good idea. ❌

I'm already feeling kinda angry. Look: Fans come here. I'm going to ignore this though, cuz I don't want to get on the bad side of a mod. But...ERG. *tries to control self*

There is already a thread for those that didn't like ROTK in this forum. It died a long time ago,bringing this one here, is like a repetitive topic.

yes. Dont dis ROTK or anything LOTR related in this forum!!!!!!1 THis is for teh fans ro LOTR, not the haters. and if a mod doesnt close this soon i'm gonna get really mad 😠 😠 😠 not a smart move

Originally posted by pip-foot
yes. Dont dis ROTK or anything LOTR related in this forum!!!!!!! THis is for the fans ro LOTR, not the haters

I agree!!!

I agree too!

some one please delete or move this before i have a break down *trys to control anger. takes deep breathes*

I gtg. keep yelling at this thread

K, bye pip-foot!

Everyone can think whatever they want about RotK, but I don't think this is really a good place to talk about how you don't like it unless your whole point is to make a lot of people really mad.