Originally posted by Dr. Strangelove
Which Cage didn't produce. I agree that production is better overall in Hell's Winter, but The Many Faces damn good also (Title track and Ode to the Wall take a bow). Let's also remember that Eyedea wrote, produced, arranged, mixed, and engineered pretty much the entire album while Cage pretty much had the dream team of hip hop producers to take care of that.I don't see where you are going with Cage being "realer". Eyedea has always raped about issues about life,love, loss etc. So what if he hasn't had a hellish childhood. I bet anyone could relate to How Much Do You Pay? in some context.
Charisma is nice, and I'll give Cage a nod in that (I'm going to try to forget about Buck 65 actually being called dull, it's too funny of a statement to even think about) but versatility and flow wise, Eyedea is better. Eyedea can do punchlines, battle rapes, story telling, commentary, comedy, diss etc. And I would love to see Cage try to keep up with Carnage for longer than 30 seconds and be able to slow down like in Step by Step. Very few MC's can vary their flows like Eyedea, and Cage certainly isn't one of them.
You say that (italic text) like it's a bad thing. Camu Tao, DJ Shadow, El-P, Blockhead and RJD2 were behind the boards for Hell's Winter. Yes, and? That can't be brought up as a negative, unless you don't actually like hip-hop. In any case, this is about lyrical skill, not production.
You know what, I'm finding this debate to be pretty pointless anyway, largely as it's completely down to personal preference and is following the usual forum stereotype of two people attempting, pointlessly and ineffectively, to get one-ups on each other. Eyedea, to me, lacks the raw energy and hunger, not to mention certain grisly life experiences that make his words all the more affecting, which makes Cage such a presence on the mic, end of story. I respect that you disagree with me, and of all the white MCs, Eyedea is definitely one of the elite few along with Aes Rock, El-P and maybe Apathy, who I would concede as being equal to him (although I'd still disagree). My favorite Eyedea song: Color My World Mine. My favorite Cage song: Stripes. Which do I like more? Stripes. Favorite Eyedea album: Oliver Hart. Favorite Cage album: Hell's Winter (obviously). Which do I like more? Hell's. Ergo, I believe Cage to be the superior artist.
And I find Buck 65 slightly dull, big deal. A few people I've made copies of One Be Lo's album for say they find him dull, and I struggle to comprehend why. He's just not to their taste for whatever reason, as Buck isn't to mine. And I think, in all fairness, Company Flow are technically the closest to a ''Radiohead of hip-hop''.
Originally posted by Dr. Strangelove
I vary in opinions with you in The Cold Vein. I don't think it is far and away the greatest hip hop album. It is certainly up ther as one of the greatest but they're other albums that are as good, IMO.
Well, then it's back to the old case of ''not IMO, though''.
Originally posted by #16
infamous, RD, ob4cl, liquid swords, R2D, LAD, HoE all >>>> than the cold vein.ask any head.
With all due respect, I couldn't care less what ''any head'' says. It seems, like every other genre, many hip-hop fans are enslaved by the so-called 'classics', and anyone who doesn't join the flock of sheep in bleeting their forever loyal praises to Illmatic and Cuban Linx, and decides that actually, music does move on and newer, more experimental things can actually be good too, are wrong. I mean, ask any head, right? They all apparently think exactly the same thing after all.
So yeah, excuse me for finding the groundbreaking, epic, ugly/beautiful genre-transcending soundscapes that constitute The Cold Vein's production, and the poetic heart and soul that Vast Aire pours into Iron Galaxy, A B-Boy's Alpha, The F-Word, Pigeon and Scream Phoenix, more than the usual ''clothes, bankrolls and hoes''. Yeah yeah, 'smh' I know, but it's really not that I don't like Nas, on the contrary, I've defended him from many a put down, especially recently, but in my eyes, nothing can even touch The Cold Vein, and I have many arguments to back up why I believe it is an all time classic (of any genre) if you want to discuss it further. So whatever, you can choose to respect my opinions or not, I've said what I wanted to say.
That was a long post. I need drugs now.