Originally posted by Phoenix
I want Johnny Depp to play Sirius!
HEY! That's an idea! Johnny Depp was my fav actor in the pirates, and he's really good, and he would be... er okay as sirius, not my imaginition (or how does it spell?), but i think noone look like i pictured sirius, although he remebers me at someone....
yeah, johnny depp would be ok, but i think i wouldn't be perfectly satisfied with anyone, cuz noone is like my imagination. but he has to be REALLY cute, cuz sirius is soo handsome!!!!!
i'm not gonna watch the third movie anyway, because i'm just too scared...
if candy says it is ok, then perhaps i will watch it some day...
i agree. not any one of the people in the movies are just like i imagined them. i dont like the movies anywhere near as much as the books. they're just not the same.
i thought of another person i didnt like in the movies. james! he looked like a nerd! he is supposed to be cool. they should have got someone cuter and cooler.
The fact that JKR killed Sirius pissed me off really seriously (haha!! Serious! Sirius! get it?! yeah I know that was dumb) Furthermore, I don't see how it was at all relevant to the development of the plot. If she thinks that she can attract more readers or make it seem more "dramatic" by killing off the most worthwhile characters, she is very, very wrong. It is possible to make a story better by having a character die (for example in LotR when Boromir died--that was the cause of the whole Faramir/Denethor thing in RotK which was sad but at the same time quite interesting to watch) but in this case there is NO POSSIBLE WAY it could have made it better in any way. Personaly, I liked Sirius more than Harry, Hermione, Ron, and all the other main characters. And yes, by that I do mean that she may as well have killed Harry. (don't hurt me too badly for saying that) The books will simply not be as good for me from now on.
I think Johnny Depp would be a good actor to play Sirius... Some other ideas: the guy who played Dorian Gray in "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen," Viggo Mortensen, Hugo Weaving, and Keanu Reeves....
ps Pippin rules!!!! His little song in RotK was really well done and that was so cool how they showed scenes of Denethor pigging out and Faramir getting "killed" by the orcs.. It really showed how uncaring and mean Denethor was
i don't think she just killed sirius to have more dramatic! he was....well, just no use anymore *cryy*
(as a matter of fact, everytime i read or here serious i think about sirius... =P)
i liked sirius way more than ron, hermoine or harry...
sometimes i even don't like harry, he is just sometimes, the..er..tragic hero (right, candy 😉) i know, i know, he don't wanna be that, but still...
and FallenForever, i think you're right! james had to be cooler and better looking, but...well, the movies....
Originally posted by Darth Revan
The fact that JKR killed Sirius pissed me off really seriously (haha!! Serious! Sirius! get it?! yeah I know that was dumb) Furthermore, I don't see how it was at all relevant to the development of the plot. If she thinks that she can attract more readers or make it seem more "dramatic" by killing off the most worthwhile characters, she is very, very wrong. It is possible to make a story better by having a character die (for example in LotR when Boromir died--that was the cause of the whole Faramir/Denethor thing in RotK which was sad but at the same time quite interesting to watch) but in this case there is NO POSSIBLE WAY it could have made it better in any way. Personaly, I liked Sirius more than Harry, Hermione, Ron, and all the other main characters. And yes, by that I do mean that she may as well have killed Harry. (don't hurt me too badly for saying that) The books will simply not be as good for me from now on.
I think Johnny Depp would be a good actor to play Sirius... Some other ideas: the guy who played Dorian Gray in "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen," Viggo Mortensen, Hugo Weaving, and Keanu Reeves....ps Pippin rules!!!! His little song in RotK was really well done and that was so cool how they showed scenes of Denethor pigging out and Faramir getting "killed" by the orcs.. It really showed how uncaring and mean Denethor was
JK was very hesitant about killing sirius. she said in an interview shortly before OotP was released that she cried after writing the death
Yeah, really...
When I first read OotP I tricked my brother by telling him that Ron died, instead of Sirius...ooh, I'm evil. Unfortunately he believed me for only about 5 minutes...but honestly, Sirius is one of the coolest HP characters (along with Lupin...okay, the Marauders are awesome...well, minus Pettigrew, of course).
yeah! voldemort could have finished of the entire world, when sirius had killed him at the end, it would been ok... 🙁
but, now, i'm afraid of dumbledore....
miiiiiiiiiiss siiiiiiiiirius sooooooooo much! but i don't think he's coming back! *crycrycry*
😉 i liked pippins song as well! it was really moving! 🙁
Sirius had to die...For 1 reason and 1 reason alone...
because you all wanted to see him live. It's all about the unexpected, except in HP 6 there's been so much speculation that almost nothing will surprise me. I bet dumbledore or a weasley gets the axe before the end of book 7. If not one of them, then probably Snape.
I hated it when Sirius died, but its probably the #1 reason why book 5 was so good.
yeah, i guess you're right! but still...🙁 🙁 🙁 it was logical, but....well there are no other words than soooooooooooooo sad! *cry*
i think dumbledore'll die too, cuz he is a really popular character,...like sirius was... 🙁
i dunno, perhaps hagrid is dying too?? oh my god, i won't survive these books...