Sirius Black [merged]

its a good thoery but sirius was not killed by voldemort, he fell through the veio. i don't think his cousin killwed him either i think he was just stunned and fell through, also it could be his double who fell through or his brother regulus or stubby boardman

oh really dont start with this nonsense "double" it was sirius alright.
sure he was not killed by bella by I think his body was destroyed(vepuride sp?) when he enter this "portal" so in another words now he is like soul, without material body,just like after life...

maybe vapor sirius will retun in book 6 and 7

I think it is good! Well researched if I might add!

xxx megajoint!

Lava

hey that makes alot of cense best theroy ive heard about that compared to some really covincing ones

regarding the theory, maybe harry can learn legillimensy and use it against voldemort so he can discover the secret of the veil.
and i think they might be trapped in the wands as well. and for reasoning you could say luna's mother had died by her own spell so she could be trapped in her wand and that's why luna hears the voices too.
like i said in other threads concerning sirius, the connection between the veil in COS and OOTP is too big to be denied.
🤨

😉😮
tnx for the support

This is VERY VERY good!!!! definitely! Good hunting and analyzing skills mega!

How would Voldemort know the secret of the Veil? I doubt if anyone, other than the people who made it or work there, know what it really is. But there are many clues in Order of the Phoenix that says Sirius will be back, you just have to know how to find them. I don't think he's even dead. Voldemort is not soul, and I don't think he is even human. Unless he is a Animagus, but whatever. I don't think Voldemort knows anything about the veil, and I don't think Sirius is dead.

Am i just invisible on this forum or something?

no your not but if you wanted to be heard then make a thread about it and ask there

it's just a theory......
and voldemort was something (he tells harry in the last chapters of book 4)
dibuk maybe...
but he hadnt got any form till book 4...
and the people that research it surly dont know its secret or else D-dore wouldnt confirm lupin answer that sirius is dead...D-dore knows all just like rowling said in one of her interviews(the one in the dvd)
I dont believe sirius will be back, but I think harry will talk to him later on in the book 6 in the form he talked to his parents (but not with the wand connection)and he will say goodbye.
another question : is the prophacy say harry will have to kill him by launching an attack on him ??
it says that :"for neither can live while the other survives"
its just say that one have to die,yes we want to assume by that that harry will have to kill him but cant he die in other ways...?
like falling into the veil...suside....traitor..etc ????
yes harry will have the power but he may not use it ....
(this assumption about harry too)
R&R

I don't think Sirius is alive...I just think he will be back.

The theory states that "Either must die at the hands of the other" therefore, Harry has to kill Voldemort, or Voldemort has to kill Harry.

that's what rowling want u to think...and all the harry potter fans follow her every word like a sheeps
soon they will found out she is a wolf....
D-dore can be mistaken we saw it back in book 5

Ya wot?

That's what Rowling wrote...there's no other way to inerpret that!

soooo she wrote it she cunning like a fox
she wont tell u what will happen next

of course she won't tell you what will happen next. If she did, there wouldn't be any more books.

hey ppl
i read this theory in some other site and this is wat they said!
they said something like
in book 2 when harry ron and Hermione are entering the death day
party every thing changes the weather gets colder the music changes and all that, these people said that at that moment they entered the veil.
BE CUZ ITS COLD.
so wat do u guys think!!!!!!
i will try to find that site and post it here.

We had this theory already, it's nothing new....