Sirius Black [merged]

well.. he could come back when he finds out dat harry is in great danger or sumthin.. not as a person.. remember Harry parents when Harry fought Voldemort in book 4?
same thing could happen to sirius.. dun mind I think it's juss a memory of James n Lily.

That thing with the veil confused me, they should've been able to check if Sirius was behind it or not...Also...i found it very saddening when Harry opened the package finally and read the note that Sirius wrote him...🙁

LiliGinnyBlack, this poem is very nice. I love it!

I agree, robincooper 🙂

ok here is ur oppurtunity to express what ways u think Sirius used to NOT die....or.....how u think he excaped DEATH once again.....
i personally think that he disapparated before he hit the curtain making the illusion of him falling behind it........ 😄

I have to agree with you 🙂

yeah sure but in an interview or osmn like that jkr said that sirius was definitely DEAD..and dumbledore even said he was dead himself....

that may be the case but think of it like this why jkr tell us something that would be happening in thenext book?????

JKR said that she cried when she had to kill off Sirius in an article i read. So i think he is dead.

I hope your right Ladyblueyes!!!! Sirius was one of my favorite characters!!

doesn't it make since though?? y would she tell the public what her intentions were?? she still has 2 more books to write!

I think it makes COMPLETE SENSE!! Yes she was sad about it...but we have NO PROOF of his death...like a body or anything.....and at the time she may have thought to have killed him off....but she may come up with another plan.....I mean...she really was sad about it..and he must've been a favorite character of hers....?? maybe not though.....

still all in all i believe that he isn't dead and that he disapparated from the room!! who is gonna take care of buckbeak??

I agree with you...and I DONT WANT HIM TO BE DEAD EITHER....

Originally posted by airangel429
I agree with you...and I DONT WANT HIM TO BE DEAD EITHER....

ok the "veil" did not kill him! he was supposedly hit with a curse by bellatrex! i dont buy that one bit though! ok look at it this way if she was gonna kill him by the avada kedevra curse then she would have written and sirius was hit with a jet of GREEN light.... but she didn't she kindly left us hanging b/c she did not say what color at all hit him!! the only time she mentioned the colore was when that one spell hit sirius and then he replied with come now is that all u got?? then she said that was a red jet of light!! so there are no facts proving his death or anything of the sort. but as for ur question, Sirius did not die from the curtain and it wasn't a curtain it was a veil

i dont think aveda kedavara is the only spell that could kill s/o thatd be totally lame. like in hp3 when harry is beating the **** out of sirius and hes about to KILL him but then lupin came....harry didnt even know about avada kedavara yet so how was he supposed to kill him if thats the only killing curse?

and ladyblue eyes shes not telling us her future intentions for the future books....it was her intention for this book! she just didnt want everybody to be convinced that sirius was coming back or that he was alive and then be disappointed when he didnt return..i mean cmon it would be a totall pissoff if u thought he was coming back and then found out he wasnt...its like closure for the harry potter geeks/fans or whatever ya wanna call em! 🤓

Hey you Guys.
Did you hate when Sirius died 🙁 He was not supposed to die Harry Was to live with him. well you can come here if you liked Sirius.

Post your reply down below for me,
Thanx, Roxy
(you can call me Roxy that will be my signed name. Not my real name) 🙂

ok u h ave a point but y would she kill off the person that cares the most FOR harry?? and another thing y has everyone forgotten about buckbeak?? he aint dead and someone will have to take care of him!

ok with disapperating there is the lil pop that is made. but as u remember people were still fighting while that happend. so u might not have been able to actually hear the "pop"