Sirius Black [merged]

but if he dissaparated, why didnt he come back immediately and join in the fight again??
and sirius isnt the only person in the world capable of caring for buckbeak....
im not saying that i WANT him to be dead, but it seems that way... but i hope harry can find a way to talk to him or learn more about him anyway...

on another site i saw a rumour that it wasnt actually sirius at all, it was regulus (his brother who was 'killed' by death eaters)

Well I was thinking...he disapperated and ended up somewhere he didn't want to end up....and that by the time he would have came back Lord V would have been gone. Sirius could have dissaperated back to his house.....it makes sense...b/c with all this going on, he would've figured the ministry was coming and he is NOT completely free yet. I am thinking...somewhere on this line..i am not sure if I said exactly what I mean..... but I tried...maybe some of you know where i am going with this.

so his brother......hrm.....that might've happened.....

yeah...but not to be mean...BUT THERE ARE TONS of threads about sirius..... but yeah he was my favorite.

Yah I bet. But it is a really important to have people in your life that cares for you. Like Harry caring for Sirius. bye,
Roxy

thanks ladyblueyes

my friend told me that the veil was some sort of evilcurtain that hides the dead. is she right? and is that why harry would have heard the voices?

that im not totally sure of...but i think that we will see sirius again in the near future.

but in a way harry will still have a godfather with him... remember at the end of the book where dumbledore says that the people we love will always be with us? near the end of the book when harry confronted nearly headless nick about if sirius could become a ghost and live in the castle i thought it would all be ok! but he can't become a ghost... but nearly headless nick also said the reason he was a ghost was because he didnt want to die... that means sirius obviously wanted to die? doest it? or well he didnt really care... poor harry... i will miss sirius... he was one of the best characters and harrys only family that could take care of him apart from the dursleys... i read that jk rowling will only write 7 books... i dont want her to stp writing the harry potter series after number 7, i want to find out what happens to harry, fred + georges joke shop, all the weasleys, hermione, ron and dumbledore + everyone else after they finish school and stuff! its soooo unfair! : no :

i so agree with u! i wish she wouldn't stop with #7!! thats so unfair to us!! grr but i guess she has her reasons. and what u said makes total sense too! but hopefully there is still hope for sirius coming back in the next book or at least in the 7th one!! we hope 🙁

Arial chocolate

Okay you guys....listen up here.....Gary can or cannot be the "perfect" guy to play Sirius....but then again who is? You just dont know until you have seen him in the actual movie! And anyhoo- gary isnt all that bad !!! Oh and just so you know....he has been playing the ruff guy for ages in all his movies and he always looked tha part! So chill out and let the good times flow! lol....

**Hermioneangel*

Ok people,
Gary Oldman way does not look the Role of Sirius! I mean Viggo would do way better than him I mean. Well I want to know who is playing Cho Chang in the movie so any info. I need to know. Thanx.
-Tonks-

gary oldman as sirius black, heard that news along time ago. i can't picture him playing black either. i'm thinking more like: hugh jackman, the guy who played faramir in the two towers (lotr), or someone like that. viggo mortensen wouldn't do either, although he is a good actor.

BOPRecruit, why not Viggo? he's dark yet good lookin ?!
I mean, u definitelly need to find sumone who looks like he's been in jail for soo long, ait?!

as for Garry Oldman, well.. we'll find out soon..well not too soon unfortunately.. (A YEAR!!?!?!?!?!?! dang! )

David Wenham played Faramir in TTT.

I don't know, maby Gary Oldman will play good as Sirius. I can't say now because I haven't seen movie yet 😉 Will see.

Unless I read it wrong, it isn't like Sirius had his heart ripped out or anything. Granted everyone thinks that he is dead and that he can't come back, but this whole mystery of that veil leads me to beleive there's a bit more to it than that.

And if Sirius never comes back, will Harry ever find a way to talk to him like he tried with the mirrior?

he can fix the mirror and why did j.k. make him open when he died? i mean after he died? he is gonna use it somehoe for some reason...

I don't think he'll be back. His death was the only solution. JKR has said it that the books will get even darker. I wish he could come back, but, IMO, he won't 🙁

i dont think he'll come back to life, exactly, but im sure that mirror will be useful for something. and i think harry will be able to contact sirius somehow, through that veil thing maybe, or learn more about him or something.

YEAH I AGREE...if he didn't really fall behind the veil and disapperated...well then I am sure he's gone for good..in LIFE...but he'll come back somehow.... even if he is stuck behind the veil and he escapes...most likely he'll be a ghost..... I wonder if the veil is like a place for trapped souls..... I wonder how Luna's mom got there...I am sure we'll find out though............. I wonder if you have to fall behind it...or if there are other ways to end up there.... hrmmmmmmmmmmmmm