Originally posted by Orlando´s Angel
yes, that point i think is has to have the + numbers of % of all the challenge ( the originally of the character ) dont you think ?like :
originality = 40%
description = 30&
reacion whith the story = 50%or something llike that . .
hmmm going back and finding things helps a lot. . .
I think we shouldn't just judge the character's importance for the story, but also how they are woven into it... I mean, everybody can invent a character and say "ooh he will kill voldemort in the end so he's very important and il get all the points", but its a lot harder to really get the story to make sense and conform with the information given in the books as far as possible... and also combine that all in a good text ^^
Maybe we could also make one category 'general impression' or so because especially in a project like a new character there are a lot of things that simply don't fit in any other category, but are very important for the quality of the result
Shall we use a system with 50 points again?