Will we find out why Qui-Gon Didn't Disappear?

Started by DocHolliday00139 pages

Will we find out why Qui-Gon Didn't Disappear?

As we know both Yoda and Obi-wan when they dies disappeared. However in Episode I, Qui-Gon did not. Will this be answered in Episode III, or not. If anybody has an answer as to why. It would be appreciated.

we will find out, and according to rick mccallum, the reasoning will piss of every fan of the EU

there has already been a thread about this.

i know why. its because qui gon didnt accept his death, because when we see obi wan die, he waited to be killed look at him he is just standing there with his eyes shut not moving, when qui gon got killed unexpectedly they disappear if they accept there deaths and stay there if they dont

i thought thats why

The Ones... that means that it's a KNOWN "trick", look at ANH, it's clear that it is something new

and Darth Jello, he didn't say it would piss off EU fans, he said it would give them a headache 😉
and Pablo, the hyperspace guy, did also say that we will find out

huh.....?

that your theory to why they disappear is wrong

if it's about being ready to die, it shows that disappearing is just a common thing to do for jedi.

But in ANH when OB1 does it, Vader is surprised by it and even goes to check the clothes to see if it's not a visual trick.

Therefor, it is something Vader doesn't know, and since he was a jedi, he knows the "tricks". So it's something new, something that they didn't tell him and quite possibly prophecy related.

Yup sorry Ones, that idea doesn't even approach the truth.

oh it boggles my mind... LET ME OF THIS SITE...

*points to the log-out button*

my theory is that yoda and obi wan were at one with the force when they died. yoda died while telling luke about vader and the other skywalker. obi wan sacrificed himself. plus, they were masters. qui gon was in the heat of battle. he was fighting then was like "dammit...is that a red blade in my chest?" he died suddenly and unexpectedly. as for anakin/vader, he was a jedi KNIGHT not a MASTER according to obi wan in ep.4. obi wan told luke this. i am guessing it is a trick known by experienced jedi masters, not knights or sith lords.
this is my best guess, and i am sticking to it until next year when the movie comes out.....

No, afraid not, suffers from the same problem, RJ.

As has been made clear, it is notrhing to do with how powerful, skilled or prepared you are. Jedi have never done it before. It is a plot point specific to the storyline of the prequel films.

well, gimmee a better theory and convince me then.

the propohecy is my best shot...

they don't know many things about it ... ("You believe it's this ... boy???" [insert annoyed; disgust; malcontent- smiles])

Anakin is the Chosen One... OB1 trained him, Yoda trained the one that had to redeem him and Anakin ...well, he's the exception cause he's the chosen one.
QGJ only recognised him, he never trained him

its too much...all too much.

the terrible pain 😄

send the pain below.

I hope we will find out.I have no theroies as to why he didn't dissapear.

we will find out, and according to rick mccallum, the reasoning will piss of every fan of the EU
EXCELLENT

and Darth Jello, he didn't say it would piss off EU fans, he said it would give them a headache
the first option sounds best

I thought that was a little weird... Clearly it's something Jedi had never done before the OT... Or Vader would've known about it

And if it had ANYTHING to do with experience, Qui-Gon would've most certainly been able to do it. If memory serves me right, he was even asked to be on the Jedi Council once or twice...