What Is The Greatest Comic Film Ever Made

Over many decades the film industry has brought in the industry of comics of many brandes.

DC, Marvel, Dark Horse.

now we decide what is the greatest comic book film created.

X-MEN2

You forgot "The Flash", "The Avengers", "Blade", "Daredevil", "The Rocketteer", "The Phantom", "The Crow", "Men in Black", "Mystery Men", "The Shadow", "Dick Tracy".

Granted, most of them suck.

But with those choices included, my vote goes to the "Blade", with the original "X Men" in a close second.

(BTW, there's an actual comic book movie section for stuff like this.).

yeah from the list given id say the original batman or spiderman, every other are just dissapointments. X2 just detroyed everything the franchise could have been, in my opinion atleast. Hellboy was probably the closest adaptation for a comic to film moive, but i just wasnt that entertained. Spiderman and batman did the best jobs with capturing the essence of there characters. even if focusing around one charactrer is easier than a group.

batman and spiderman were good but i went with superman....that movie paved the way for the rest of the comic movies

yea i do respect the old superman films they did do alot, im just not for their idea to make a new superman film

Hellboy was a damn good movie, Blade 2 is hard to top tho.

I didnt care to much for the X-men movies, both of them might as well have been Wolverine spin off's. I mean isnt Cyclops the leader? not some short putz with 5 lines.

still entertaining tho I would just have liked a little more of the rest of the team

yeah in the comics u do see the team more involved the second film was mostly about jean, and the other half bout wolverine,

but for some reason i still think the whole dark presense and mystery of batman in the 1st film had me hooked, i really love it when the authorities and the public hate the hero. gives it a nice touch.

blade had that, batman had it and spiderman had it for a few scenes.

I liked hellboy, because it wasnt too bloody, it was a bit funny, it showed more of his personal life, it gave you more about the super-hero. I will always like spider-man however, so, yup. I liked hellboy though, and the punisher was good.... but too... murderous.

yes i see very bloody comic films to be somewhat fake if it was an independent comic such as Spawn i would understand but DC and Marvel comics w/ extreme blood i see to be wrong

spider-man

X2 or superman 3

I voted batman from the list, but if there was "The Crow" that woiuld be my choice. If u would kindly rent the DVD and see the special features u will find the interview with the maker of The Crow, and u will see that The Crow was really greatly adapted for the big screen. Oh, and Blade also falls into this category.

batman:mask of the phantasm

yea batman mask of the phantasm was pretty good, it was better than batman forever and batman and robin combined its the #3 batman movie.

X2

this poll only shows that comic fans arnt the people that like the new movies

As film witha good story/acting superman is very hard to beat.Its' like watching mythology when you watch it. Spiderman paved the way for the new age of comicbook movies IMO.I know blade and X-men were before it but spidey whooped ass on a huge scale and appealed to critics aswell as fans.Daredevil is prob the most faithful comic film Ive seen but I hear Hellboy is too, but I haven't seen it yet.

like i said earlier superman was a great film the 1st one

and you were RIGHT!!