What Is The Greatest Comic Film Ever Made

MIB II was disappointing Men in Black 1 was good

know 0ne beats blade 1-2? i like batman 1-2 as well and spiderman 2 will
rule when that comes out

Well I think there is a tie between X2 and Spiderman for the Greatest Comic Film in my opinion. Superman and Batman were also good but Captain America with Eric Roberts... (i think) sucked its own ass big time. Plus the Spiderman soundtrack was off da chain I mean just listen to "Hero", Batman and Superman wish they could have got that song for their movies. 😠

the hulk movie was all wrong the story did not work. where was rick jones, the lab accident was wrong and nick notle as a villan he sucked!
the hulk plot took to long the dog fight was ok but ang lee srewed up
worst hero film ever

superman is a classic and batman. i think a new superman film would be ok if they follow the smallville plot and used more powerfully villans like braineyac and lobo or darkside. the batman begins will be good to.

yea its good to go back to the mystery and dark nature of batman, unlike the last two batman films made him corny such as the television show did

now hopfully the new batman film protrays batman correctly for the first year, batman has to kill criminals like that, he has to be wanted by the authorities, he must be the vigilante he always was.

Batman doesnt kill anyone. he never has.

excuse me u never has? he use to be a vigilante, kill the criminals who opposed the common good, the old comics he did so, in the graphic novel Batman year one which the new film is based on he killed, he was a vigilante meaning he took the law into his own hands, he stopped killing after the first batman movie, or around the time period when he was taken in by the law and accepted. but he did kill in the past.

give me an issue where Batman has killed. Year One was a graphic novel out of continuity. writers do all kinds of shit to characters that are out of the character's normal behavior in one-shots. dont tell me youve never noticed that.

In the Batman comic, 'Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight, batman is a total vigilante and in the most part in almost every issue he kills a criminal.

still batman is a very dark character, as is blade that is also why i like blade the dark and mystery about him, pretty much any hero whom the law is against i love.

Originally posted by Drifter101
In the Batman comic, 'Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight, batman is a total vigilante and in the most part in almost every issue he kills a criminal.

Batman: Faith arc: Villians killed: 0
Batman: Prey arc: Villians killed: 0
Batman: Fear arc: Villians killed: 0; villians Batman risks his life to save: 1

Got counter-examples?

It's also made clear in Fear that James Gordon completely trusts Batman not to kill anyone, to the point that attempting to frame him would be pointless.

Besides, Legends of the Dark Knight stories aren't in continuity.

Thank you Gregory, for helping prove my point. I dont exactly have the largest Batman collection ever, so i couldnt really prove it.

I've said this before and I'll say it again. When they adapt these books to movies, it's a given that people like us will generate the largest chunk of revenue, because we're very likely going to watch anyway, even if we don't like it (except for the Hulk, which I couldn't stomach at all--I tried, I really tried to watch it, but had to bail). As comic readers, we have to accept the fact that each title adapted will contain a certain number of anachronisms--it's a necessary evil: unfortunately, if the creators want to introduce all the characters and subject matter that they want, they have to cram it all in to a comparably tiny time-frame.
I think we could all pretty much nit-pick most of the titles, but what would be the point? I try my best to just enjoy the different spin, and not cling so rigidly to my expectations. Afterall, the adaptations are meant as tributes, truly labors of love by those who make them, for the benefit and enjoyment of the rest of us.

superman is awesome...