Originally posted by carver9
You made a thread based on Green Lanterns and Surfer space cheese fits and you just made a thread not too long ago asking who could replicate Superman moon building ft. Yes, you care a lot about it.
Originally posted by abhilegend
It was all feats included carter. And Yes I did, but I don't use those feats in every thread like you do.
In a Thor vs Supergirl thread you mentioned Supergirl moon showing ft (a long with other cheese fts) as justification of her being stronger than Thor...
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t657528.html
Destroying moons...
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=657346&pagenumber=2
First 2 threads I clicked on that i knew you listed in had you mentioning space cheese fits.
🙂
Originally posted by carver9
In a Thor vs Supergirl thread you mentioned Supergirl moon showing ft (a long with other cheese fts) as justification of her being stronger than Thor...http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t657528.html
Destroying moons...
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=657346&pagenumber=2
First 2 threads I clicked on that i knew you listed in had you mentioning space cheese fits.
🙂
Originally posted by abhilegend
No, he wouldn't. Supergirl has a pretty impressive record in combat against beings like Thor (Substantially weaker than Superman).
First response again.
Originally posted by abhilegend
New 52 Superman was superior to post crisis Superman across the board save extremely high end feats for post crisis Superman.
I only brought up space cheese when the other posters brought it up.
Originally posted by carver9
In a Thor vs Supergirl thread you mentioned Supergirl moon showing ft (a long with other cheese fts) as justification of her being stronger than Thor...http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t657528.html
Destroying moons...
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=657346&pagenumber=2
First 2 threads I clicked on that i knew you listed in had you mentioning space cheese fits.
🙂
Originally posted by Khazra RebornIn a non-PIS fight Thor would win every time by just teleporting Hulk into a black hole or something. But comics have PIS to keep them entertaining; so Thor instead stands there trading physical hits with no significant speed difference.
For real, I don't even see how this is a question. If this was Hulk vs. Thor in these circumstances there'd be no question of Hulk's superiority.
Surfer amped by Loki. Thor still won.
From Silver Surfer(Vol 1) #4: https://imgur.com/a/NVZY8UX
Loki-amped Surfer was beating Thor easily. Yes, Thor was holding back, but neither one of them were sure they should be fighting. More importantly, there was plenty of PIS, as neither even used any of their more hax powers.
Surfer with Beta Ray Bill, and Adam Warlock. Thor shits on all three of them. And keep in mind, Surfer proclaims to the world on panel, in big ass capital letters that he's no longer holding back, so there goes that argument.PIS is PIS, not matter what characters say. When Superman says he's not holding back, but doesn't use superspeed, what do you believe, his words, or his entire publication history showing that it’s in his powerset?
Thor is mortally wounded, and Surfer has a supposed "upgrade". What happens? Right again, Surfer still can't get the job done.You mean when Galactus comes for Odin? You did notice the whole time that Surfer didn’t actually want to fight, right? And when he saw Thor’s injury he actually lowered his guard out of concern?
The fight was stopped by Sif before they actually got serious. And again, as usual, the plot had them trading their basic atacks, not using their whole powersets to their fullest.
Also, as for the whole "Warrior's Madness not being an amp" argument, that is debateable. But a side issue.
If you look around the internet, you'll see that "Warrior Madness Thor" is always treated as a unique version of the character for the sake of VS threads.
Bill tells Surfer Thor draws strength from his madness--in fact, Bill beats Thor one-on-one at first, then Thor talks to his hallucination and gets up suddenly strong enough to one-shot Bill and easily beat Surfer.
Compared to his entire history, where Bill and Thor are pretty close in power and Thor and Surfer always stalemate, this one-time performance is, if not an amp, at least some sort of outlier. It's definitely NOT his normal outing.
Some other evidence includes Warlock stating that Thor is more powerful than he remembered from their last fight, Moondragon (with the Mind gem) saying he is invigorated by his madness; and Thor later stating that "berserker rage"(which is how non-asgardians would have called warrior madness, according to several previous comics) makes him 10x stronger.
I don't think any of this is truly definitive, especially since Odin calls what happened to Thor not "true" warrior madness, with no real explanation. But the general consensus among fans seems to be that it qualifies as an amp.
Your mileage may vary.