dumb, you say? He may not be as quick on things as Jack, but he's sweet and soo adorable! Uncomfortable, he may be, but thats because he feels like he really doesnt belong...hes battling with himself over whats right and wrong and its leaving him in an awkward stage. He's not cocky at all, which Jack is all the time, but, hey! He's Captain Jack Sparrow...(the cockiest line in the movie). and yes he tries to be perfect, who in this world doesnt?
will is cocky tho!
J: who makes all these
W: i do. and i practice with them for three hours a day
...(some other lines)
w: i practice with them for 3 hours a day so that when i meet a pirate, i can kill it!
come on tell me that's not cocky! an he always has such a smug look on his face. and he talks to hammers. and does stupid stuff and is really slow...he's so uptight too!! he needs to relax a bit!
an its ok for jack to be cocky because he is as amazing as he makes himself out to be!