Comments?

I was lookin at the Episode III reviews on amazon.com and some guy named Ryan Lockwood had this to say:

"George Lucas clearly did not make the original Trilogy because the most recent incarnations of Star Wars are not only the worst in the series, they are the worst movies ever made.

If you don't agree with what I'm saying, ask yourself this question: "If this movie wasn't based in the Star Wars universe, would I still think it's so great?" Clearly the answer is no. These movies are terrible and George Lucas should be dragged into the street and shot."

Well If I tried to imagine watching Star Wars for the first time by watching episode 1 first, would I still like it? Well yeah I think so. It still has more imagination than Dude Wheres My Car, and could be argued to be better than The Matrix Trilogy. Why would I, and probably many more would still like it.

2 Words: Light Saber

That weapon, and the duels alone will make you interested in watching the whole saga. Also no other sci-fi movie will ever use a laser sword, and if they did, they are only doing a comedic parody. Believe it or not Star Wars has never been a great emotional expierences from great actors, instead they have basically always been great eye candy, and entertainment with an amazing story and great characters in a fantastic world. And episode I has all of that, if you think about it.

I have always been interested in finding out how future generations will look at these films. Mainly because they will have a different outlook, and I think their opinions will be more honest, and not so much biased like Ryan Lockwood's.

he should be shot

Who?

whats wrong with this moron?

he says the PT are the worst movies ever made, then compliments episode 1.

why even post this nonsense?

Some people thrive on negativity. They crave it.....

There some things here and there that could have been better with these movies, but the main story is interesting.

looks like the reviewers are getting walmed up already to trash ep3 when it comes out no matter how good it is 🙁
I just hope they give it a chance and not load every review with mentioning how 'awful' the other prequels were (but why dont I think that is going to happen???)

Wayne..

He says it's the best eye candy ever, but the worst movies.... Hmmm, sounds arguable. 😈

its just a silly review, pointless to even ponder it.
if it brought up any points, i would say different, regardless of their opinion.

The thing to remember is that none of the Star Wars have ever gotten great reviews that I can recall.

How... neutral of you. 😄

well, im willing to lend an ear to a well thought out arguement.

this is just mindless rambling though.

i feel like i've lost some braincells just from reading it.

Hey folks. Read what's being "QUOTED" and what's the original poster's own words. Adobe QUOTED (it's a little thing that happens when you use these signals,", to indicate something someone else has said or written) the bad review and then went on to defend Episode 1 with his/her own comments about the laser swords and the eye candy.

Learn to read and maybe we won't have so many trolls fighting all over the place.

A review with no meaning! how could you take it out of its setting?? hmm how errrr interesting, it seems to be the fashion for reviewers to slate star wars, this ryan guy should have at least thought about what he was going to write and maybe use constructive criticism? 😮‍💨

he was jst posting his opinion because he probibley not even a starwars fan hell if I met him I probibley punch in the face because if george lucas had'nt made ILM we would'nt have most of movies we have today so he really should rethink who he is talking about.

A review with no meaning! how could you take it out of its setting?? hmm how errrr interesting, it seems to be the fashion for reviewers to slate star wars, this ryan guy should have at least thought about what he was going to write and maybe use constructive criticism? 😮‍💨

Originally posted by zutalurs
Hey folks. Read what's being "QUOTED" and what's the original poster's own words. Adobe QUOTED (it's a little thing that happens when you use these signals,", to indicate something someone else has said or written) the bad review and then went on to defend Episode 1 with his/her own comments about the laser swords and the eye candy.

Learn to read and maybe we won't have so many trolls fighting all over the place.

whatever ther case, there are no trolls on this thread.
nobody is bashing adobe. no need for anyone to be put in their place here.

i misunderstood, is that a criminal act?

Negative on the troll front, wasnt havin a go at adobe just the reviewer

Originally posted by PVS
whats wrong with this moron?

he says the PT are the worst movies ever made, then compliments episode 1.

why even post this nonsense?

Calling him a moron for YOUR mistake? Sounds like bashing to me.

i was referring to the reviewer, seems like you should follow
your own advice.

and furthermore, a patronising tone like the one you take, instructing me on what quotation marks are, are insulting.

so is telling someone to learn to read.

just a pointer

i was referring to the reviewer, seems like you should follow
your own advice.