Frodo at the grey havens [merged]

hi everyone,

Just saw movie and loved it. But I haven't read the book and I was wondering why Frodo had to go away at the end? Please help

dat was so sad, bless all the hobbits they were so gutted. i could tell something was wrong as he wasnt cryin when the others lefted.

i wondering that myself, maybe it was to find his true peace as he said he couldnt go back to normal

in the book frodo goes in place of one of the elves arwen i think because his grief of the ring and his wounds is too much

this is nothin to do with the orginal question but it iz to do with frodo. omg frodo topless would of prefered it if it was legolas but still omg he looked good, looked less good near the end but not the point

they didn't change it from the book did they?

yeah it confused me too at the end.

Frodo leaves in the books too. It wasn't a change. Actually if truth be told after Rosie dies Sam also crosses the sea as do Legolas and Gimli after Aragorn dies.

I am rusty but Frodo was unhappy and that is why he left. In the movie it felt like only Sam's life had really changed in the shire when they get back. But that is not true. Frodo becomes mayor of part of the Shire when they return.

How does it end???Details plz 😱

It wasn't because he was unhappy, that Frodo left. All ringbearers leave together with most of the elves. Frodo's wound was just to deep. And he couldn't heal anymore.

Gilraen is correct. Frodo couldn't return to a normal life after that so he was allowed (I guess thats the best word) to leave Middle Earth.

uh i didn't see the movie and I KNOW THIS..

The ringbearers all went to Valinor sometime or the other
And for frodo its true , he had to go to get healed properly.........the samn thing happened to Celebrian(Arwen's mother) she was injured in middle earth so she left of Valinor.

hey now that you have seen the movie..........please go read the book

it was a bittersweet ending, in that frodo did what he set out to do - save the shire, but when he got back, he couldn't be happy in the shire any more.

Aren't the undying lands a kind of allegory for heaven? I mean, Beren and Luthien meet there again etc.

I guess you could put it that way cermiestar! That's what I would have thought.

A little off topic but...: Did anybody else find it beautiful when the hobbits had completed their task and they run out of the mountain and they fall upon the ground, exhausted. And then Sam breaks down, his hope gone, and he comments on marrying Rosie. Well, I love the way that Frodo and Sam seem to switch roles there: Frodo becomes the comforter, not the one to be comforted - beautiful! 😄

Ya know fini I don't think there is ONE overwhelming reason why Frodo left Middle earth. None of the ones listed are incorrect, or more correct than the others.

all ring bearers must leave middle-earth. thats what I got from the books, Sam leaves eventually to, because he was a ringbearer in the books for alot longer than he was in the movies, he even uses the power of the ring and puts it on in the books.

awwww that was a wonderful ending, a wonderful ending to a wonderful triology, i bawled my eyes out as frodo was getting on the ships with the elves and sam, merry and pippin were crying, i bawled alot during this movie, it was absoulutly amazing and i so cant wait to see it again tomorrow night! BLESSED!

OOOO seeing frodo naked was interesting, my eyes got big because im a big lij fan, so seeing lij skin was like WOW! I wish that would of happened with legolas too, see some orli skin! Which by the way..legolas was absoulutly amazing in the film, fighting with the elephant and everything and he was just so..wow..he looked like an angel!

But yes...seeing frodo leaving with the elves was a sad sad moment, it felt as if i was saying goodbye to frodo myself, saying goodbye to all the characters, when it said "the end" i broke down, because of the thought that its all over, no more lotr films after this! I have tissues left over from lastnight that im keeping in my purse for tomorrow night, because i know ill cry again!!

Originally posted by OrliNElijahsGrl

OOOO seeing frodo naked was interesting, my eyes got big because im a big lij fan, so seeing lij skin was like WOW! I wish that would of happened with legolas too, see some orli skin! Which by the way..legolas was absoulutly amazing in the film, fighting with the elephant and everything and he was just so..wow..he looked like an angel!

Me and my friend were hoping for a butt shot...but i guess since it is only PG-13 they left his pants on but in the book Frodo was butt naked! ✅ And check out my site (its in my siganture) if you wanna see some Lij skin.

lmao me too, i was hoping to see some lij bootie, but no..the pants were left on, darn the luck but still...WOOOOOOOOOT! got to see some lij skin!!!

WOOOOOOWWWW! that is a hot pic of lij on your site *drools*

okokokokok YOU TWO stop that crap right now.............go drool in a THREAD MEANT FOR DROOLING..................this isn't the place for it

sheessshh

aw wa wa, we are still talking about the film, we just mentioned a scene, big deal

dont ruin our fun

anyways...I CANT WAIT TO SEE ROTK AGAIN TOMORROW NIGHT!!!