Frodo at the grey havens [merged]

Sam left the shire 'cuz Rosie died, his 13 offpsrings are quite old now, and he would be quite old.

and after his first wife died he wanted to see his first true love 😄 lol

come on youv all seen the jealousy whenever someone even looks at frodo < look out for it seriously, in fotr when he throws pippin off frodo, he never even looks at pippin his eyes never leave frodo

Well they ARE Soul mates.

i have a question, mabey i dont understand and it wont get through my thick skull but does frodo die? i read that book more than once but i still dont understand.?????

I am sure he died in Valinor, yes - living among immortal folk doesnt make you immortal yourself, I think.

oh okay because i wasent really sure because for some reason i though he came back.

Came back? No, he surely didnt. He wanted to live his remaining years peacefully and without his pain in Valinor.

yah thats what i thought. thank u.

anyone know how old frodo lived?
also sam? he's crackin' just like that old bilbo.

ok so were is middle earth??? and y is it called middle earth ??

ps im not a real big fan of lotr so plz exues my n00bynes 😕
Thanks!

nah frodo was just over 50 when he went to Valinor (52 or 53 i think), considering he left the shire with the ring when he was 50.

Sam had to go to valinor, although not in the movie, he was a ring bearer for a very short time and allllllll the surviving ring bearers went to valinor, i guess to purge them of the evil.
But he did that after many many years( he was around a 100).

legolas and gimli went to Valinor too( i think with sam, someone clear that up pls). aragorn died, so did pip, merry, faramir, eomer, etc.

uh matrix 4 ever ,middle earth is europe, you see the elves left, the dwarves died out and so did the hobbits, leaving the earth to the RACE OF MEN. 😂 its MYTHOLOGY so dont take it literally.

Frodo Baggins of course went to Valinor (Undying Lands) with Gandalf the Maia, Elrond Halfelven, Galadriel, his uncle bilbo and many others. in rotk novel, aragorn never reaches the undying lands but perishes with his people in gondor (he dies of old age, but lives to quite an age-about
120); thus arwen dies of grief. gimli and legolas are the last of the fellowship to leave middle earth and go to the undying lands. In the undying lands the elves dwell, along with the maia and valar spirits and of course eru, the one. For full details see the appropriate appendix at the back of the lotr books.

Lalalalal, but guess what?? NAZGULS STILL ROME THE EARTH!!!!!!

Originally posted by Matrix_4_ever
ok so were is middle earth??? and y is it called middle earth ??

ps im not a real big fan of lotr so plz exues my n00bynes 😕
Thanks!

READ THE FRICKIN BOOKS! IF YOU WOULD READ THE BOOKS, YOU WOULDN'T BE ASKING THESE STUPID QUESTIONS! Geez.

NAZGULS STILL ROAM THE EARTH!!!!!!

No they don't. They perished when the ring was unmade.

Also, Aragorn lived to be 210 (but did die in 120), and couldn't go to the Undying Lands because no mortal was allowed to do that. Well, the hobbits did go, but that's probably because they earned the respect of the Maiar and Valar. It's not clear on why Gimli was allowed to go (or if he really did), but being the friend of an elf doesn't really explain it.

Originally posted by eldarion
Is that (Valinor) where elves go, if they die on middle earth, to be reincarnated?

Are they really reincarnated? They go to the halls of Mandos (or something like that), but then they don't become alive again, do they?

As far as I remember Elves killed by disease or in battle (or by other 'unnatural events'😉 were gathered in the Halls of Mandos (where men also went) and taken from there to Aman (Undying Lands), the continent of which Valinor was a part.

Also, though I'm not positive on this, Glorfindel was killed in the First Age, and obviously there was a Glorfindel in the Third Age. If it is the same person (though I'm not sure, but believe it to be) he was one of the few, if not only, to return to middle-earth from Aman.

Originally posted by PippinTook
READ THE FRICKIN BOOKS! IF YOU WOULD READ THE BOOKS, YOU WOULDN'T BE ASKING THESE STUPID QUESTIONS! Geez.

Too bad. You should.

No they don't. They perished when the ring was unmade.

I know this....I was making myself feel better.