Lucas confirms......sort of

Started by Jedi Priestess12 pages

LMAO Ush.....thats been the whole forum the last 2 weeks pal.....you've missed all the arguing.

Originally posted by zutalurs
Oh. So pasting that picture after quoting my thread wasn't starting something?
What a big man you are [b]P
enis Very Small.

Someone burns you and you act all high and mighty like you never meant an insult. You are a HUGE wank. [/B]

^^^^^
well, there you have it

understood ush, im done with this nonesense

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Good Lord... can we stop the schoolboy squabbling please? Else I shall have to close.

So long as you follow this thread back and see who started being a wank first. I have no fear of your threat.

So I see. Well, it is certainly going to stop now, else warnings are going out.

*sigh* ok then, so:

Originally posted by PVS
now cipher, proof that tarkin does not believe in the force is in his dialogue,
so i will agree. "you are all that is left of their religion my friend"

but vader has no problem preaching his "old religion" to tarkin does he not?
why would ha have not said "i suspect kenobi may still be helping the rebels"

Don't take this the wrong way, but why the heck would I care?
I only came here for the free Hyperspace pics. And now that they are gone, there's not much point in coming.
PVS dominates EVERY thread and if you say something and for whatever reason he doesn't like what you say, then he insults you. Of course, if you retaliate then he puts on airs and acts as though you are the troll.
This board is moronic, and mainly becuase a moron runs around with nothing better to do with his life than post non-stop.
And he is stupid enough to wonder why so many people Sock him and troll him.
Hell, that's the only fun in this site anyway, making fun of PVS. You should change the name to "Poke the Wank."

If you don't care, don't come. Simple as that. Other than that, I don't care what you have to say on the matter; keep up this attitude and you will be gone, and whether you care or not makes no difference to me.

ok then, lets try again:

Originally posted by Cipher
Stuff involving the Force probably ranks above Tarkin's clearance....
This might depend on whether the ghost of Qui-Gon makes an appearance.

now cipher, proof that tarkin does not believe in the force is in his dialogue,
so i will agree. "you are all that is left of their religion my friend"

but vader has no problem preaching his "old religion" to tarkin does he not?
why would ha have not said "i suspect kenobi may still be helping the rebels

nice info. 😉

Tarkin believes in the Force: he sees Vader use it right in front of him.
The remark about his clearance was meant as humor....

As for him not saying anything, I'm not really sure. That part has me at somewhat of a loss..... Maybe he tells the Emperor but he doesn't think Obi can be actively involved with Luke? Maybe the idea of Luke being trained by a ghost seems impossible to him- and who's to say he's wrong? Ben does send Luke to Dagobah so that Yoda can teach him.....

^^^ how could Tarkin not beleive in the force after seeing Vader use Force Choke... likely he has seen Vader use the force many times but as others beleives he is the only one left who has those powers

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
LMAO Ush.....thats been the whole forum the last 2 weeks pal.....you've missed all the arguing.

Yes, it's good to see the influence of my return is so clearly noticed. 😈

PVS, you make a good point about yet another annoying plot hole, but these other people don't seem to be saying "here's a theory i made up, check it out".....they're saying "here's yet a nother annoying plot hole, if we have to live with it, maybe we can think of a way it can be explained"....and then having a damn good stab at it....if it is true, and we have to live with this, i think zutalurs and cypher make the most convincing attempts so far....perhaps there is talk of this "force ghost" syndrome, but no one's actually done it, and details of what it entails are unknown to everyone involved....so when vader sees obi wan die, he either doesn't recognise that he's just seen the act performed (having never seen it before to know what it looks like), or he's saying "so he actually might have worked out how to do it, interesting" but he's not 100% sure that it has happened, just curious and fairly confused.....

and by the way everyone....lucas did know vader was luke's father when he made epIV....he did he did he did he did.....

he didn't he didn't he didn't 😆

it's all through the script it's all through the script it's all through the script it's all through the script.......

no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt no it isnt

about 10 people mention luke's father with heavy knowing looks in the first hour of the film...."he's got too much of his father in him" "that's what i'm afraid of"....you know how to read movie subtext don't ya? it's obviously all hinting at something....what you think eventually they were gonna reveal that the pigface man in the cantina was really luke's father?...

Originally posted by guiro72
about 10 people mention luke's father with heavy knowing looks in the first hour of the film...."he's got too much of his father in him" "that's what i'm afraid of"....you know how to read movie subtext don't ya? it's obviously all hinting at something....what you think eventually they were gonna reveal that the pigface man in the cantina was really luke's father?...

"your father wanted you to have this, but your uncle wouldn't allow it"

"He feared you might follow old obiwan on some damn fool idealistic crusade like your father did"

Vader being Luke's father was always the story.....

Lucas couldn't make up his mind about the brother/sister thing, though.

Originally posted by Cipher
Vader being Luke's father was always the story.....

Lucas couldn't make up his mind about the brother/sister thing, though.

I'll never believe this and it can't be proven.

I think Vader being Luke's father is the biggest cheese-out in history. It's about the only thing that really has ever bothered me about the series. Well, Leia being Luke's sister is worse, but that couldn't have happened without the soap opera ending of ESB.