Lucas confirms......sort of

Why would he tell the Imp. officers "the old guy just vanished"?
And he could easily be lying to the Emp. inESB....

ok, one last time:

anakin learns of a technique, granted he might not know the specifics.

kenobi gloats to vader "if you strike me down now..."

vader witnesses ben VANISH and wonders what happened.

SO, why did vader not say ...Hmmmm maybe....just MAYBE that was what they were talking about...perhaps i should reflect on this

I don't see any contradiction that can't be reasoned out- if this ends up being true. Misunderstandings happen... Yesterday, PVS, you thought Vader was just an empty shell in the OT.....

no cipher, i misinterpreted the article,
and to my glee and MUCH appreciation you pointed that out.
if it had not been for you, i might not have gotten to sleep that night.

Originally posted by PVS
ok, one last time:

anakin learns of a technique, granted he might not know the specifics.

kenobi gloats to vader "if you strike me down now..."

vader witnesses ben VANISH and wonders what happened.

SO, why did vader not say ...Hmmmm maybe....just MAYBE that was what they were talking about...perhaps i should reflect on this

Well, he probably was on his way to do just that when he got a call from Palps.

Palps: Yo Vader. Whazzup?
Vader: Just meditating, having a Bud.
Palps: True, true. Oh wait, get your ass over to the Death Star ni**a! Some fools be trying to blow that sh*t up!
Vader: Damn fool. Now I forgot what I was thinking about.

Who's to say he didn't? Some of this stuff you're just supposed to figure out on your own.....
Vader didn't tell the Emperor everything....
Again, do you think he copped to trying to use Luke to overthrow his mater?

MAybe that was a bit harsh, PVS. You kind of frustrated me the other day...

If this is true, I can see it working with the old movies....

Originally posted by Cipher
MAybe that was a bit harsh, PVS. You kind of frustrated me the other day...

If this is true, I can see it working with the old movies....

no cipher, that was not sarcasm.
you pointed it out, i realised, and was very much relieved.
i was under the belief that anakin USED the technique before becoming vader...the thought of which nearly drove me mad

Originally posted by Cipher
Who's to say he didn't? Some of this stuff you're just supposed to figure out on your own.....
Vader didn't tell the Emperor everything....
Again, do you think he copped to trying to use Luke to overthrow his mater?

but vader told tarkin in his victory speech "it has seen the end of kenobi"
END is END...not kind of the end...or maybe the end...no

it means he's dead
finished
done
six feet under
finito
pushing up daisies
he has ceased to be
he is no more
etc....

Believe me, I would've hated that, too.
Anakin waking as Vader strapped to a table like Frankenstein's monster is close enough to old sci-fi...

This new stuff could fit but is unconfirmed, who knows?

Stuff involving the Force probably ranks above Tarkin's clearance....
This might depend on whether the ghost of Qui-Gon makes an appearance.

Originally posted by zutalurs
Well, he probably was on his way to do just that when he got a call from Palps.

Palps: Yo Vader. Whazzup?
Vader: Just meditating, having a Bud.
Palps: True, true. Oh wait, get your ass over to the Death Star ni**a! Some fools be trying to blow that sh*t up!
Vader: Damn fool. Now I forgot what I was thinking about.

©cowboyography 2004

That fat kid is disturbing......

Originally posted by PVS

©cowboyography 2004

Wow. Your mom is HOT!!!

oh great, another childish putdown.
when in doubt, play the dozens.
now i suppose if i match your level of insults
you will rant like "HOW DARE YOU"
and things of this nature?

well you've been a part time troll from the get-go.
you try to wind me up and it wont work.

it is not working.
it has not worked.
and it will not work.

and thats all i have to say to you.
good day sir

Oh. So pasting that picture after quoting my thread wasn't starting something?
What a big man you are Penis Very Small.

Someone burns you and you act all high and mighty like you never meant an insult. You are a HUGE wank.

Good Lord... can we stop the schoolboy squabbling please? Else I shall have to close.

Originally posted by Cipher
Stuff involving the Force probably ranks above Tarkin's clearance....
This might depend on whether the ghost of Qui-Gon makes an appearance.

now cipher, proof that tarkin does not believe in the force is in his dialogue,
so i will agree. "you are all that is left of their religion my friend"

but vader has no problem preaching his "old religion" to tarkin does he not?
why would ha have not said "i suspect kenobi may still be helping the rebels"

Hey Jersey Girl. Do you ever not have to have the last word? Twice?
Go ahead. Post two replies to this post. I dare you.