Original Trilogy DVD- Discussion thread

Started by moonwalker74121 pages

original version

special edition

2004 edition

oh and also, when threepio crosses the droid sensor in the cantina, they took out that sensor sound..sorry, im a little nit picky

Originally posted by Xanatos
Does he ever think of how much money he could make if released the OT on it original format. With just better picture quality.

Not as much as the Special editions, you'd be surprised how few actually like the O-OT better than the special editions which are far superior.

this is all they had to do!

but NOOOOOOO!!!!

As far as those pictures go, it looks blue to me.

This might be just me, but maybe the green saber might have something to do with the color restoration. If not their is major fuk ups with these movies, and I'm not talkin about Jabba and Hayden (I'm fine with that stuff I don't really care). But green and pink light sabers, and missing music I am not okay with.

You guys with the sound problems, and other complaints I think there is a possibily we will have recall on our hands. Maybe

Did they fix the way Luke looks when he falls in Empire Strikes Back? Because that has always bothered me...

ooooo fun fun, fun with photoshop! 😛

😂 that's great, Moonwalker...

Seriously, I could have redone those lightsabers in 5 minutes in Photoshop and it have looked better...🙄

I think it looks Damn good.
The OT is probably SO old taht they Had to add some more stuff. and completly change it.
But I thought I was cool how they added stuff, like the womp rats in ANH to fill up a scene

Originally posted by Silver Stardust
😂 that's great, Moonwalker...

Seriously, I could have redone those lightsabers in 5 minutes in Photoshop and it have looked better...🙄

Originally posted by moonwalker741
this is all they had to do!

but NOOOOOOO!!!!

I sold my VHS set, but where the Dejarik pieces always colored? I may confusing them with the holograms, thinking ALL the pieces were blue.

so many new additions to the movies, its not the same as the old triliogy.

i still havwent gotten used to seeing heyden in rotj.

lukes saber doesnt look as bad while watching the movie.

Originally posted by Mist
i still havwent gotten used to seeing heyden in rotj.

He has all of 7 seconds of screen time. Are you people seriously obsessing over this?

Originally posted by Silver Stardust
😂 that's great, Moonwalker...

Seriously, I could have redone those lightsabers in 5 minutes in Photoshop and it have looked better...🙄

Frame by frame? You would have had to quit your day job buddy.

when Obi and Vader fight there is this greenish light occuring when the sabers clash

Originally posted by cal31
He only pissed off the fans who have no life other than to moan and complain that he ruined his own movies and pick apart every detail instead of enjoying a movie.

Not as much as the Special editions, you'd be surprised how few actually like the O-OT better than the special editions which are far superior.

Cal, this isnt true, I personally dont give a damn about these kinds of things, in fact I dont understand the Rancor lines that people complain about I've never seen them.

But what I do NOT understand is why people who obviously arent serious fans of SW feel the need to attack the rest of us who are?
I have supported GL's right to make HIS movies the way he saw fit, but the dvd release was quite a shock for me who has never seen the SE's and was completely suprised at a movie thats been revised twice now.

I think that the only group that prefers the SE's to the Original version are the people that saw them first. If you saw the OT in its theatrical release back in the 70's & 80's the SE's suck IMHO.

I agree that some of the changes are quite unnecessary, but Lucas isn't always going to listen to what the fans want, he's going to do what he wants to do, and obviously by what's happened, nobody's going to stop him. I thought you would've seen the SE's, JP. I can imagine the shock to see the 2004 editions and skip the 1997 SE 😖 But they made Jabba look so much better than in 1997 in ANH, so look back at that and be happy that there was something legitimate. 😛 🙂