Captain America vs. Wolverine

Started by jinzin164 pages
Originally posted by Alfheim
Hell it even seems to me that also when it comes to Wolverine verything is acceptable. Wolverine threatens Namor therefore Wolverine assumes that hes not going to fight back, its not because Wolverine wasnt fast enough to dodge the punch its because he wasnt expecting it.

It IS because he wasn't... Likewise, Namor getting punched by Wolverine is because he wasn't expecting it right?
See how that double standard works?

Wolverine clearly threatened Namor before he had his claws at Namor's head, then he went for the fake stirke, had he not stopped we would have been treated to filleted fish man.. I suppose that's because Namor's not fast enough right?
Or perhaps because he wasn't honestly expecting Logan to attack..

Logan's a government spook, he USES SCARE TACTICS... sometimes they don't work, it doesn't mean he's always looking for a fight.

Like Wonderman, Wolverine threatened to chop his arm off if Simon didn't let him go, Simon stood firm, Wolverine smiled and commented that Simon had some balls on him then they talked...
Wolverine had his claws right at prof X face... one slip and "Chuck" was dead, didn't mean he was looking for a kill.

It's really simple.. Logan wanted Namor gone, he was prepared to fight Namor if he needed to, but he didn't resort to violence first, instead, Namor STARTED the fight, Logan was ready for a fight, but not ready for the first punch...
especially coming from an "ally".

You put both characters in a situation where Logan's ready to resort to physical viloence off the bat and Namor gets aced in 5 minutes guaranteed.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Furthermore if any one is completely honest if theres a fight with Wolverine and Cap. Cap should be able to out strategise Wolverine and not the other way round like in Origins.

There was no damned out strategizing... Again, explain yourself.. you keep saying that Wolverine out thought Cap, Wolverine just did what he always does and kicked Cap's ass... so what?

Originally posted by Alfheim
Every man and his dog knows its bad writing hell even a review said that Wolevrine and Cap were acting out of character.

Ah so because a FAN review said so, that makes it so?
As long as it's in tune to your OPINION huh?
Cause no matter how many "fans" say that cap loses this fight... here you are... 😐
Cause when MARVEL says that Wolverine and Cap are equals in combat, or hell, that Wolverine is Cap's SUPERIOR, that doesn't count, or it's bad writing or PIS... right?

It's double standard bullshit Alf, that's all it is.

Explain how either hero acted out of character..

Wolverine was being badass and hostile, Cap was being controlling and "knowing what's best for everybody", seems like it was in character to me, and lets keep in mind that I've been reading more comics from either of these guys than you have, I oughta know.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Its an absolute disgrace that a starving and tired Wolverine can out think Cap at his peak. We all know what hunger and lack of sleep does to your thinking and performance how does Wolverine manage to do that to somebody who is better at strategy and is not tired?

Do what? Beat Cap with skills that he doesn't have according to you?

Oh I dunno, maybe it had something to do with the fact that Wolverine ragained all his memories, including every mission and bit of training he's ever had before he fought Cap, maybe it has something to do with the fact that Wolverine knows the darker side to the inner workings of the givernment better than cap does, maybe it has to do with the fact that Wolverine didn't out think Cap, he just fought him to a stalemate and his superhuman qualities owned Cap where it counts (in healing)...

Originally posted by Alfheim
Hell with Caps experience he could have forseen it.

Again, be specific here: what the hell are you talking about?

Originally posted by Alfheim
Hell since every Wolverine feat is acceptable im pulling Cap being able to hurt Korvac and KOing hulk. I'll give Wolverine the majority when people start being more reasonable.

Well start with yourself then, you claim that Wolverine's less skilled when logic, stats and history dictate otherwise.

You've basically claimed that Wolverine doesn't practice his skills in spite of MULTITUDES of stories displaying the opposite.

You dictated that Cap could KO Logan even though Logan's KO count against BRICK fighters is staggeringly low compared to his number of sheer fights with them.. legit KO's; even worse.

You keep saying that the Origins fight is bad writing and that Wolverine outstrategized and out-thought Steve, but you NEVER explain how so.

Now you want to use that Loeb induced stupidity of Cap KOing Hulk regardless of the fact that it's 1) with Spidey help. 2) off panel for the most part. And 3) clearly insulting to Hulk when you consider HULKS ENTIRE HISTORY vs. Steve's only options of attack?

Okay.. how about this then: Let's use the Wolverine who killed multitudes of super guardian elite from the Shi'ar empire (soldiers who were capible of leveling a city by themselves), a feat that phoenixes of the past have failed to accomplish.

or Wolverine that fought Gladiator for six days straight.

Knocked out Hulk with BONE CLAWS.

Cut through Thanos with BONE CLAWS.

Killed Silver Surfer.

or destroyed his entire team of X-men in the Astral Plain...

Cap's good, Wolverine's better.

Logan knows it, Steve knows it, Zartan knows it, SHIELD knows it, Mr. X knows it, Mr. T knows it, hell, everybody knows it!

Originally posted by Soljer
So I've heard. Wouldn't it be possible to make a 75% respect thread, and let Srank add his when his lazy ass gets back on the scene?

well i suppose, but it would really mess up the organization which was half the reason of making a brand NEW thread in the first place.. I am glad to see you're excited about it though, at least SOMEONE is besides me.. hehe...

though after I'm done with my other several respect threads I think i might prefer to never scan another image again haha!

Originally posted by jinzin
well i suppose, but it would really mess up the organization which was half the reason of making a brand NEW thread in the first place.. I am glad to see you're excited about it though, at least SOMEONE is besides me.. hehe...

though after I'm done with my other several respect threads I think i might prefer to never scan another image again haha!

Yeah I'm also looking forward to it, it definetly needed to be organized

Welcome to my world 🙁

😂

Just make it, damnit. 😛.

doh

*shakes fist* If you want to be popular you will have it done by tuesday ie. tommorow🙂

Originally posted by King_Mungi
*shakes fist* If you want to be popular you will have it done by tuesday ie. tommorow🙂

No, if he wanted to be popular he'd have it done by tuesday, I.E. three hours from now. 😛.

honestly i think the match is too close to call. Cap is better hand to hand than wolverine but not by much but over all duriblity and stamina goes to logan so the battle can only go 2 ways: stalemate via interferance or battle grounds being destoryed or logan would win due to a long drawn out fight

Originally posted by Soljer
No, if he wanted to be popular he'd have it done by tuesday, I.E. three hours from now. 😛.

Well that's cruel..*thinks about it* I like your style

😎

Originally posted by lando005
honestly i think the match is too close to call. Cap is better hand to hand than wolverine but not by much but over all duriblity and stamina goes to logan so the battle can only go 2 ways: stalemate via interferance or battle grounds being destoryed or logan would win due to a long drawn out fight

Are you ignoring that in said 'long drawn out fight' there would be a number of clashes? And that Cap's clashes with Logan's claws will have a MUCH different result than Logan's clashes with Cap's shield? 😬.

🙁

impossible I'm afraid.. Both the disk and the file that I made to hold all the links to Wolverine's greatness are at home, I just moved up to college. Again.... even without Sranks rienforcements I would still be looking at launching this thing at some point during the weekend, possibly (very slim chance) thursay evening...

But seriously, everybody go harass Srank, send him annoying messages constantly, and maybe he'll finally send the damned hosted links to me so I can organize the damned things. I really want this thing to be as complete as possible.. when you spend as much time on these things as I did, it's the little things that count I suppose.

Originally posted by Soljer
Are you ignoring that in said 'long drawn out fight' there would be a number of clashes? And that Cap's clashes with Logan's claws will have a MUCH different result than Logan's clashes with Cap's shield? 😬.

Just got one sentence for ya:
Two sets of claws and one shield spells doom for the flag wearing boy scout.

Originally posted by Soljer
No, if he wanted to be popular he'd have it done by tuesday, I.E. three hours from now. 😛.
Originally posted by King_Mungi
Well that's cruel..*thinks about it* I like your style

😎

🙁

I wanna be popular!

Originally posted by jinzin
Just got one sentence for ya:
Two sets of claws and one shield spells doom for the flag wearing boy scout.

Proof he has two sets of claws? I'm not afraid to call P.I.S

Originally posted by jinzin
🙁

I wanna be popular!

One day..one day

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Proof he has two sets of claws? I'm not afraid to call P.I.S

😠

If I wasn't so sick and tired of scanning shit!....

Originally posted by King_Mungi
One day..one day

🙁

(*runs off and cries manly tears of badassery*)

Originally posted by Soljer
Are you ignoring that in said 'long drawn out fight' there would be a number of clashes? And that Cap's clashes with Logan's claws will have a MUCH different result than Logan's clashes with Cap's shield? 😬.
I'm not ignoring anything i'm just calling it how i see it there wont be many clashes at all between cap's body and logan's claws maybe one or two before the point where cap is so tired he cant even stand straight then it's easy pickings for wolverine

Originally posted by jinzin
😠

If I wasn't so sick and tired of scanning shit!....

How convient 🙄

If I knew how to spell P.I.S I would type it...*cough*

Originally posted by Alfheim
Strategy is involved in one and one combat thats why Boxers say "My plan was...."

Which is a rough plan but ocne the fight stops he either sticks to the plan or doesent. He does not come up with new plans it all instinct. Also boxing is an awful example because it completely different from a real fight. UFC guys are a far better example. They go in it with a game plan, but after that it skill and instinct that gets them through it. No rough game plan is going win capt or wolverine the fight.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Yeah but it thaty height he has superhuman durability and Cap was weakened and dying so he would have had been very difficult to injure him.

No really. It would still require the same skill………do you even do MA? Ro know any thing about it because some of the stuff you say really implies you don’t.

Originally posted by Alfheim
So that doesnt change the fcat that the nerve was a superhumanly tough nerve and Cap was weak and dying. Remember this Goliath is actually Hawkeye. Hawkeye is probably better trained than Roughhouse.

Hawkeye also extremely cocky and makes retarded moves a lot back in the day. He held capt right near his nerve……..it takes really no skill to hit a huge nerve cluster when some one is holding you up to it.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Well whatever it was still a good feat.

Still useless to your argument and shows that you have a general misconception about what skill implies.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Punching him in his face. But remember he was dying and weaker and Yellowjacket was not

Really doesn’t matter since yellowjacket is not a skilled fighter in the least. Also what was capt dieing from?

Originally posted by Alfheim
Well this is the thing I have a detailed reveiw and as I suspect you were exaggerating lying. He was not dying and he his healing factor was not maxed out because after the guys got arrested he healing factor had healed his arm. No he was not at his peak but he still had his healing factor and claws.

I was not and now your gunna look foolish. On the last page Wolverine goes I would “applaud if I could” I implying heavily that his hand was still broken. So much for your shitty reviews. There was nothing that suggested his hand was not still broken.

Originally posted by Alfheim
No after the fight his arm was fully healed. During the fight his healing factor was still working but not as good.

Nope it was not and his arm was not fully healed after the fight as I explained above. Your going by a review I have the issue right in front of me.

Originally posted by Alfheim
You know what its an impressive feat but its still not as good as Caps.

Really and why is that? Nothing in the feat you mention was above what Logan did vs Rough-House

Originally posted by Alfheim
Wolverine has to use his claws to beat both BloodScream and Roughouse if he did not have his claws he would have been dead.

So would capt……..Nerve strikes won’t work on Bloodscream he completely immortal and his healing factor is likely the best in the marvel universe.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Why did Roughouse give up, he gave up because Wolverine would have popped his claws through his neck.

Your point? He still used massive amount of skill and beat Rough-house. Who by the way wolverine was fist fighting with a broken hand and likely many other broken bones.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Why did Bloodscream get ****ed up its because Wolverine cut open his stomache.

Actually it was the chest and it the only way to put Blood scream down. He can’t be damage by any thing man made and Blunt trauma does nothing to him.

Originally posted by Alfheim
What did Cap use to take down Goliath and Yellowjacket..his bare hands...Cap doesnt have healing factor and claws to help him.

Capt fought people who were trying to contain him not Kill him.
Capt also had two good hands
Capt had not been totured dozens of times before the fight either.
Not to mention Capt did not fight opponents on the level on Wolverines
Wolverine healing factor was completely maxed out.
Goliath defeated hims elf by putting capt right near his nerve in his head……..
All capt really did was fight yellowjacket who is a joke any ways.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Hell it even stated in that issue that Wolverine said that he was a sloppy fighter due to his adamantuim.

That was never stated in the issue

Originally posted by Alfheim
It shows that if didnt have a adamantuim bones and a healing factor he would have been DEAD.

It actually shows nothing to do with comics……..man has your hatred of wolverine finally caused you to go crazy?

Originally posted by Alfheim
Never said Wolverine doesnt use skill hes just not as good as Cap.

But he is as good as capt and every one else can see this but you

Originally posted by Alfheim
Yeah im biased thats why even Wolverine said in Wolverine 123 that his adamantuim made him sloppy.

that was never stated in the comic, but nice job talking out your ass…….
.

Originally posted by Alfheim
He still doesnt have anything as good as Cap though.

But he does your just to bias to realize that.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Wow so when boxers fight ecah other they dont use strategy. 🤨

They do as a game plan before hand, but when the fight starts it mostly skill and instinct. Strat is used more in boxing then an actual fight due to having gloves and beign so one dimensional. In a real fight or in UFC fighters have game plans that about as much strategy as they use.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Of course thats why he had to eat his arm.

He had to eat his arm because his heart was cut in haft……

Originally posted by Alfheim
Cap should be outhinking Wolverine not the other way around.

Why? There about the same intelligence. Again like I said it skill and instinct in one on one melee fight. Strategy goes out to window once your in the thick of it.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Er bro wolverine is weakened so Cap could figure out that Wolverine would use different tactics. .

Dude it a fight. Capt not going to have time to be thinking all this when some one as fast and skilled as him is attacking him. Not to mention there so many attacks Logan could use there no way in hell capt could know that Logan would attack that way. Your beign ridiculous.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Korvac saga.

Which you have been unable to prove that he was infact training or fighting the majority of the time.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Well saying that wolverien didnt expect namor to punch him for starters is illogical.

When was that stated in this thread?

And still you have been unable to give a good reason why Captain America beats Wolverine.

Im more then willing to help on the respct thread jinzin.