I don't necessarily agree with Rogue beating Hulk, but remember that Claremont CREATED Gladiator. That's HIS character. Gambit is his character too. If he says one of the characters he created can do something to another character he created and knock them out, well...
But I agreed with most of the battle results in COC. Storm is his favorite character and she was EASILY owned by Thor. Panther, after an epic battle, was edged by Captain America. I felt all the results were believable, so I have no problem with that issue or the portrayals of the characters involved.
But...that's off-topic.
Anyways, I just don't think any amount of rain or wind will beat him. Wolverine extinguishing him is ridiculous.
It would be if it were isolated. Off the top of my head:
Punisher did almost exactly the same thing to Torch, with a fire hose
Hulk extinguished him with a clap
AIM agents extinguished him with foam guns
Gets extinguished pretty much as soon as he hits any body of water.
BTW - that was Millar's Wolverine, not Claremont's, in case you were about to get angry at him again.
And even if Storm couldn't extinguish him with rain, she can create a vacuum that removes air from a localized area. Without air, Torch can't combust.