in coc gladiator and gambit didn't fight. and if your refering to the end where rogue beat everyone- it wasn't really her, someone was inside her body which made her more powerful and she had like everyone mind controlled so they didn't even try to fight her until they were all done. and even if it was fan based people have already said that they think it was fair. torches flame can be exxtinguished easily, it has happened many times before. storm has many options of winning this fight.
It was on Marvel.Com when the books were concepts.
It provided the back story then asked who should win in a fight. Fans voted. Claremont overode some of them to get the win for Rogue, coz fans voted Hulk.
Either way, all that is irrelevant to Storm Vs Torch. If you use C.O.C, then it's gonna be different result for you. For me it's not.
-AC