sidious = sifo-dyas

what if palps killed the real syfo-dyas and stole his name to use it for the clone army?

Maybe.

it makes sence. if syfo-dyas was in aotc it could be sidious using the name but not actually be him.

But Syfo-dyas wasn't in ATOC, he died at TPM's time.

sifo dias is NOT sidious, thus this thread is misleading and pointless.
perhaps close and ressurect the old "who is sifo dias" thread?

Is their not going to be any good threads today?

i was told that palp finds holocronz when he is a kid with the secrects of the darkside.

i dont no if this is True or not anyone no?

Originally posted by LandoSpeeder
Is their not going to be any good threads today?

You're afraid for today. I'm afraid for next months. 😕

Unfortunately. 🙁

I'm afraid for May! Not about Episode 3 itself, but about the number of threads that will be opened on "The Movie was Great" or "Who's Seen it?"

Jango Fett- " I was recruited by a man named Tyranus."
Tyranus = Dooku
Jango was the original from which all clones came.
Jango was recruited from the beginning by Dooku.
Dooku uses the name Sifo Dias to order the clones
THAT SIMPLE!

Originally posted by PVS
sifo dias is NOT sidious, thus this thread is misleading and pointless.
perhaps close and ressurect the old "who is sifo dias" thread?

oh, you've seen episode III already then?

There's not supposed to be an explaination on this in Episode 3 anyway. 😬

Originally posted by jedijunky1138
Jango Fett- " I was recruited by a man named Tyranus."
Tyranus = Dooku
Jango was the original from which all clones came.
Jango was recruited from the beginning by Dooku.
Dooku uses the name Sifo Dias to order the clones
THAT SIMPLE!

wow ; thats really simple !

so was Sifo Dyas Master or Apprentice to Dooku ?

neither, Sifo Dyas was A JEDI! He died after TPM. the only POSSIBLE argument is if he ordered the clones by himself. If he were a Sith, im sure he would attack the Jedi knowing how everything about them(as does Anakin). Plus Sidous picked up Dooku right after Maul anyway. One thig i heard is Sidous or Dooku had a changling morph to look like Sifo Dyas to order them. Dath Sidious is Palpatine and that sit. they have their real name and their Sith name. Ani - Vader....Dooku - Tyraunus....Palpatine - Sidious.

Does it really matter? You'll find out in May.

if your answer is "you'll find out in May" then theres really no point of this website. we're all here to discuss theories an dour thoughts and feelings. So, will we find out in may? yes.
Does it matter? well it must if people are talking about it.

what do ya think?

I think that you dont have to waste your time thinking about something so minor as if Sidious is Sifo-Dyas especially since you will find out in May.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
neither, Sifo Dyas was A JEDI! He died after TPM. the only POSSIBLE argument is if he ordered the clones by himself. If he were a Sith, im sure he would attack the Jedi knowing how everything about them(as does Anakin). Plus Sidous picked up Dooku right after Maul anyway. One thig i heard is Sidous or Dooku had a changling morph to look like Sifo Dyas to order them. Dath Sidious is Palpatine and that sit. they have their real name and their Sith name. Ani - Vader....Dooku - Tyraunus....Palpatine - Sidious.

first off, you're forgetting that it's not unusual for jedi to talk about people dying from "a certain point of view". Apparently when you turn to the darkside, it's somewhat the same as dying. secondly he could've been a fake jedi the whole time, while really being a sith... and could've FAKED his death.

ok ill give you one thing ONLY because of the look that Mace and Yoda gave each other when OB1 said, "i was under the impression he ws killed 10 years ago." NOW, that could mean 1 of 2 things: 1. they are now insure of Sifo Dyas' death, or 2. they know someone posed themselves AS Sifo Dyas. So i wont say what youre saying is impossible, just improbable.

I still dont beleive that he is Sidious though. If he were the Jedi would know because if he were a chagling himself(Sifo Dyas that is), then they might be suspicious if Palps just showed up when he "died". So i dont think thats the case.

And Someguy57, i dont mean this to be rude or anything like that, but if you dont feel this is a topic worth ddiscussing, than you can simply not click your mouse to come in here. I dont know how else to say it. Im NOT saying F. off, im just saying, i know theres some threads in here that i too think are pointless and i just dont go in there, especially just to say how insignifican tthey are, like the "how does OB1 get anakin's lightsaber?" i think we all already know, and theres no point to it...but i dont comment in there.....again no disrespect or rudeness.......and yes..we will find out All these answers in May, youre right.