Should the voting age be changed to 16+?

Started by Evy_O17 pages

Maybe 16 year olds follow politics, but a correct, mature and not one-sided opinion/belief is MORE than knowledge... it needs experience too. And that's something most 16 year olds don't have ❌

that's quite a generalisation though

How many 18 year old have experience when they first vote either? This is only a 2 year difference, we're talking about.

Originally posted by yerssot
that's quite a generalisation though

Indeed, I have to say I resent that comment. I'm 16 and I know many of my classmates are mature. All the junkies and potheads on the streets everywhere that are 16, etc, give teens in general a bad name. Quite sad, really.

(Good heavens, you people post fast. This is in response to §pearhead's question)

My first point would be to ask, why shouldn't sixteen-year-olds be allowed to vote? Obviously, you have to draw a line somewhere, but are eighteen-year-olds really so much more mature that they should have a say in how the country is run, but sixteen-year-olds shouldn't? I don't think so.

I'm having trouble putting my second thought into words. But it goes something like this...

Who decides how much money is spent on education? People who are not in school.

Who decides what environmental policies to enact? People who will be dead by the time bad environmental decissions catch up to them?

Who sets the town curfews? A bunch of stuffy adults who think that the youth in their town are a bunch of no-good delinquants.

And on and on. In many ways, it is the government that decides what sort of quality of life its teenagers enjoy. And I think that its teenagers should therefore have a say in the government.

the difference between a 16 year old and an 18 year old is huge....you just might not know it yet because you AREN'T 18 yet

I believe Evy is 16, Jkozzy... or at least close.

I disagree completely with Gregory- I think it is a function of government to regulate things FOR teenagers.

Originally posted by Gregory
I'm having trouble putting my second thought into words. But it goes something like this...

Who decides how much money is spent on education? People who are not in school.

Who decides what environmental policies to enact? People who will be dead by the time bad environmental decissions catch up to them?

Who sets the town curfews? A bunch of stuffy adults who think that the youth in their town are a bunch of no-good delinquants.

And on and on. In many ways, it is the government that decides what sort of quality of life its teenagers enjoy. And I think that its teenagers should therefore have a say in the government.


same goes for prisons:
who deceides how to run them? not the ones in it 😛

Originally posted by Linkalicious
the difference between a 16 year old and an 18 year old is huge....you just might not know it yet because you AREN'T 18 yet

I hope you weren't addressing me, because I'm nineteen. And I don't think the differences are as "huge" as you make them out to be.

no i was adressing §pear...and yes i know you're 19. As huge as i make them out to be? i didn't give an example to compare to...

He was addressing ignorant me. After all, I'm only 15, not even 16--why should I care about politics? 🙄

Ushgarak: And when the government decides to slash the school budget? Some job they're doing looking after the teens then, huh?

yerssot: I find your comparison between teens and convicted criminals unsettling. One group has willfully given up he right to live in a free society. The other group has not.

Linkalicious: You make them out to be huge enought that one group should have a say in our government, and the other shouldn't. I do not think they're that huge. Hence my statement.

just giving examples Gregory 😄

nah it's not like that §pear. You mai boy n you know that. You're not ignorant and I do understand that you may have some valuable knowledge to share. But the general majority of 16 yr. olds AREN'T like you....they are more like the citizens of California who vote for someone like Arnold Swartzenegger (sp?) because he's a popular movie star.

And those are the adults who vote for him...seriously, imagine if teens did vote? 😖

alright the HUGE difference between a 16 year old (since it MUST be that huge for you to comment on) and an 18 year old....is that 1 is an adult and the other isn't. There's my huge arguement...

Originally posted by §pearhead
And those are the adults who vote for him...seriously, imagine if teens did vote? 😖

The porn star wouldve won! 😱

Originally posted by §pearhead
And those are the adults who vote for him...seriously, imagine if teens did vote? 😖

Then he would have one by a land slide...i'm guessing.
But he's still better than Gray Davis.

^damn you Kozzy...you're right, she woulda won.

Originally posted by Gregory
Ushgarak: And when the government decides to slash the school budget? Some job they're doing looking after the teens then, huh?

Err, just beause Governments sometimes do things badly does NOT destroy the principle of my point, not in the slightest!

yerss> Yes, it might be a generalisation, however you cannot base on the fact that some DO know AND have correct judgement. The ones that COULD vote are the minority.

And Jkozzy- I am 16 1/2 too, Ush is right. I'm not saying that because "I think myself as mature" and stuff. I started realising politics only last year. And I think I need some years to, in order to form a completely MINE opinion.

Most people I know that are my age, don't even know what right/left/center is... 🙄