rate the sig of the person above you.

Started by Rogue Jedi3,342 pages

Originally posted by Vinny Valentine
Do you not still have it?
I do, and it is prolly one of the top two or three in my collection to this day, but I got tired of looking at it. As far as craftsmanship goes, Lana/Peaches sigs are one of a kind, hard to match.

My sigs I make are VERY simple and I am OK with that, at least until I can afford photoshop.

I have GIMP, but the elite sig makers here tell me photoshop is the way to go.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I do, and it is prolly one of the top two or three in my collection to this day, but I got tired of looking at it. As far as craftsmanship goes, Lana/Peaches sigs are one of a kind, hard to match.

My sigs I make are VERY simple and I am OK with that, at least until I can afford photoshop.

I have GIMP, but the elite sig makers here tell me photoshop is the way to go.

damn right we do uhuh *pretends to be elite*

lol, download ps ftw, I done that.

Now that I've seen the whole image. I dunno. Seems lacking compared to the whole.

And you've done a lot better anyways.

Still, a 9 😄

yeah i agree 😂

7,

not a major fan of the style of animation Star uses.

plus has all that excess black at the sides, really unnecessary.

10
Scarlet Speed ftw.

Originally posted by ScarletSpeed
yeah i agree 😂

7,

not a major fan of the style of animation Star uses.

plus has all that excess black at the sides, really unnecessary.

The animation part I like but, I agree the black around the sides leaves something to be desired. But, he's already done a few drafts for me and I didn't want to keep asking "K, that's cool but, could you do this?" 😆

That and I've another lined up which I plan on using when I'm bored with this one.

yeah i seen the other one 😛

Originally posted by TKM
Oops, I forgot the extra 'o';like you never made a mistake.

well... for a person who's entire sig theme is PERFECTION!!!

I got your opinion and I thanked you for it. You questioned me and I gave you an answer but you still didn't get it.
i didn't see it... what am i looking at? i think i see a Pokemon in the bottom left corner and some randomly placed stars and text.

but ya... i don't get it. what you need to do is get a image that matches your concept... like perfection, maybe show something that's perfect? instead of a bunch of imperfect stars?

This is just constructive criticism, please take it with a grain of salt and a bit of 'i can make a better Sig if i listen' I'm not an expert either. i just know what i like and don't like.

10

8.7

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
well... for a person who's entire sig theme is PERFECTION!!!
i didn't see it... what am i looking at? i think i see a Pokemon in the bottom left corner and some randomly placed stars and text.

but ya... i don't get it. what you need to do is get a image that matches your concept... like perfection, maybe show something that's perfect? instead of a bunch of imperfect stars?

This is just constructive criticism, please take it with a grain of salt and a bit of 'i can make a better Sig if i listen' I'm not an expert either. i just know what i like and don't like.

The point of the 'Perfection' theme is that nobody will reach perfection because nothing/no one is perfect. I didn't make the sig;a friend did it for me. If I was to make my own sig I wouldn't use computer generated images. I would draw it out myself and scan it on to the computer.

You are not criticizing me you are criticizing the work of somebody else. So , I will not take what you are saying into consideration.

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
i think i see a Pokemon in the bottom left corner and some randomly placed stars and text.
That's Kirby you noob.

Originally posted by TKM
The point of the 'Perfection' theme is that nobody will reach perfection because nothing/no one is perfect. I didn't make the sig;a friend did it for me. If I was to make my own sig I wouldn't use computer generated images. I would draw it out myself and scan it on to the computer.

You are not criticizing me you are criticizing the work of somebody else. So , I will not take what you are saying into consideration.

so tell me this,

if you aren't taking what he is saying into consideration, then why did you want us to give you a reason for our rating 😬?

Originally posted by TKM
Someone is gonna have start putting some reasoning behind why they are giving me such low numbers.

Originally posted by ScarletSpeed
so tell me this,

if you aren't taking what he is saying into consideration, then why did you want us to give you a reason for our rating 😬?

At one point I think I said I was just curious and I only asked you for your opinion not both of you.

Originally posted by TKM
At one point I think I said I was just curious and I only asked you for your opinion not both of you.

fair enough 😂

10, Holy hell i cant belived i miss all this chaos. Can i join in ? awesome *pats TKM's head*

7

9 hell yes to WEEZER !!!!

10

1