rate the sig of the person above you. · The Off-Topic Forum

ScarletSpeed Authority

lol harsh

9

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Indeed 😂

9

Agent White No title since 2009-07-25

7.5

Mywi healed ninja.

Originally posted by ScarletSpeed
lol harsh
9

well i was gonna give it a 3 but then i changed my mind, that sig doesnt deserve a 3. 😐

AW- 8.5

Rogue Jedi Restricted

8

Dorian Belmont the harbringer of doom

KICKASSS!!10 Dante PWNS

Mywi healed ninja.

Wow, when will people stop stop give sigs ratings depending on their theme? Ridiculous, imo.

The Grey Fox Restricted

Originally posted by Mywi
Wow, when will people stop stop give sigs ratings depending on their theme? Ridiculous, imo.

true. I have no idea what yours is, but it's amazing, and looks very very well made, so 9.5/10

Scythe The Goat

8/10

ScarletSpeed Authority

7

Originally posted by Mywi
Wow, when will people stop stop give sigs ratings depending on their theme? Ridiculous, imo.

yeah I agree, it's annoying as a sigmaker.

however it is the OTF, you can't expect people who don't make sigs to be able to judge technical ability 😂

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by Mywi
Wow, when will people stop stop give sigs ratings depending on their theme? Ridiculous, imo.

I think themes plays a role in rating. Like yours, I rated 1 to 5 on theme/craftsmanship. I gave it a 3 and a 5. Not really feeling the theme, but the work is excellent.

Scythe The Goat

EDIT: Scarletspeed... LYKE WHOA! SONIC TEH HEDGEHOGGIE! 8/10!!

Rogue Jedi Restricted

8....and late haermm

ScarletSpeed Authority

5

I think a sig should be judged on quality and how good it looks in general as a sig.

at least in this particular forum.

Scythe The Goat

8/10 Scarlet, what's going on in that pic??

ScarletSpeed Authority

Originally posted by Scythe
8/10 Scarlet, what's going on in that pic??

Sonic opening up a can of HedgeHogFu.

The original picture is amazing,

I've posted it already, but I'll post it again cause it's so hot

Mywi healed ninja.

Originally posted by The Grey Fox
true. I have no idea what yours is, but it's amazing, and looks very very well made, so 9.5/10

Thank you, its from the lovely PS2 game, Okami.

Originally posted by ScarletSpeed
7
yeah I agree, it's annoying as a sigmaker.
however it is the OTF, you can't expect people who don't make sigs to be able to judge technical ability 😂

yeah its a little annoying and, youre right..

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I think themes plays a role in rating. Like yours, I rated 1 to 5 on theme/craftsmanship. I gave it a 3 and a 5. Not really feeling the theme, but the work is excellent.

Thank you. Personally I never judge sigs by their theme, only by how well made they are technically.

SS - 9
Some text would make it look even better, imo

Dorian Belmont the harbringer of doom

awesome 9

Scythe The Goat

Originally posted by Mywi
Scythe -5

Negative 5? Uh oh! How can I improve it??

ScarletSpeed Authority

Originally posted by Mywi
Thank you, its from the lovely PS2 game, Okami.
yeah its a little annoying and, youre right..
Thank you. Personally I never judge sigs by their theme, only by how well made they are technically.
SS - 9
Some text would make it look even better, imo

I tried it with text, but it sucked too much.

Originally posted by Scythe
Negative 5? Uh oh! How can I improve it??

Nothing you could really do to make that better from where Mywi is coming from, it doesn't really have any effects or anything.

I would suggest making it smaller, making the border black and smaller.