rate the sig of the person above you.

Started by One Free Man3,342 pages
One Free Man Restricted

Originally posted by Vinny Valentine
People in this thread rate way to easily.

There isn't a signature on this page that deserves over a 5.

Minus Imps, Id give him a 6.

I find the lack of anti aliasing around the curves on the edges of your Sig disturbing. If you made it a little smaller and saved it as a png you would fix this.

The center of your triptych is way to vague, you can't tell what it is and you can barely make out the outline of the guy so you can't tell where the gun on the bottom right corner is from. Also, you can see a lock of hair coming outside of the crosshair which would never happen in a gun scope. It has poor balance, and is a triptych, which is a rather amateur move, imo.
4/12

harsh enough for you?

steverules_2 Senior Member

We're doing this out of 12 now? 😕

mikeydude Cleveland is the Reason.

?!? when did this happen? 😑

One Free Man Restricted

Originally posted by steverules_2
We're doing this out of 12 now? 😕
It's a little empty on the edges, 9/12

One Free Man Restricted

Originally posted by mikeydude
?!? when did this happen? 😑
I like it. It is a little empty and 2d, you can visibly see the layers between text and the render. integrate the text and you've got a nice one. I like the red stripe. I also like the change in color. 8/12

Scythe The Goat

5/10

We're not doing it out of 12, do the thread right guys, come on.

Impediment Endless

8.8

steverules_2 Senior Member

7

Impediment Endless

5.

All you do is blur the outline around a render. There's nothing to it....

TRiNiTYfemi Constantly Evolving

9

One Free Man Restricted

Originally posted by Scythe
5/10

We're not doing it out of 12, do the thread right guys, come on.

12 is both divisible by 4, 3, and 2.

Impediment Endless

8/10

TRiNiTYfemi Constantly Evolving

rated

One Free Man Restricted

Originally posted by TRiNiTYfemi
rated
6. it's a bit empty.

Scythe The Goat

4/10

Originally posted by One Free Man
12 is both divisible by 4, 3, and 2.

Doesn't matter, it's not how the thread goes, learn...

One Free Man Restricted

10/12.

I will do what I want.

Scythe The Goat

4/10

Okay, that's understandable, though I may suggest instead of listing things wrong with a sig, I've always found it useful and cool to point out the highs and lows. Like, your sig for example:

I like how it is crisp, not choppy at all, and the shadow around it giving it a 3D look is what I gave you mad props for, I think it's awesome. Very nice!!

But it isn't original work, and although you like the image, I am not a fan of smileys at all, though I have seen your work, and it is quite nice. Your other sigs, I would score much, much higher.

Impediment Endless

One Free Man, the standards of this thread are 10 of 10.

Get used to it.

Glenn, you get a solid 9 because you are my goat boy.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by Vinny Valentine
People in this thread rate way to easily.

There isn't a signature on this page that deserves over a 5.

Minus Imps, Id give him a 6.

What's it matter?

Imp: 9

steverules_2 Senior Member

Originally posted by Impediment
5.

All you do is blur the outline around a render. There's nothing to it....

You gave a guy who got a picture of google, made it smaller, added some shadow to it to make it look a little 3D an 8.8 and then you give me a 5 when I actually didn't blur anything...I smudged the render, I made my own background and I even made the render I actually made my own sig from scratch, so clearly thats not blurring anything 😉 I think you're a little un-fair with the way you rate, I may be a little silly saying that to a mod but yeah there ya go