Originally posted by Nathaniel Grey
Hard call. Mobility is on the Panther's side but SHEER endurance, strength and skill is on Wolverine's. I'm leaning towards Logan on this one. Black Panther could slash Wolverine up all day but it wouldn't do much good since the man heals neigh instantly and he takes assault weapon fire heads up without flinching. ( Especially when he's feral. )The best Panther would hope for would be to KO Wolverine with his knockout agent or use one his knowledge of pressure points. Maybe he could immobilize him but even that would be a task considering Wolverine's no slouch.
black panther would get killed
Originally posted by capt it up
actauly thats not true at all.
adamtium was created form tryign to make vibranium but in no way does that make it stronger. vibrannium and adamatium are both umbreakable niether can destroy the other.
Sorry i meant that in theory if his claws were vibranium still (in theory) could damage adamantium
They would in theory damage vibranium for any material can damage itself
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Anti-metal can't cut adamantium, it can't cut any metal for that matter. What it can do is emit a vibration that weakens any metal in the area at the molecular liquefying it. Primary Adamantium is to durable to be liquefied though, when Pym attacked Ultron with Antarctic Vibranium, Ultron's body was weakened enough that after a beating it shattered. So it can be weakened to the point where someone with superhuman strength can shatter it. Would Black Panther's anti metal claws damage Wolverine's claws? Who can say. Logan's adamantium is different then Primary Adamantium in that is an amalgamation of bone and adamantium (it's called Adamantium Beta), and while it has been shown to be as strong and durable as Primary Adamantium it is at least in part organic which would make it less subceptable to the effects of Antarctic Vibranium.
Sorry for DP but i do know this and was actually trying to clearify the difference in he is claws vs his shield
so ppl do not think of them the same
"Both wrong.
Adamantium was created to replicate Caps shield (which has vibranium in its mixture.)
Adamantium is unbreakable, vibranium is not. There was an island thats foundation was pure vibranium, it was blown up. US Agents shield was vibranium and it was cleaved through by an adamantium knife.
Black Panther's suit not being bure vibranium but a vibranium microweave would not be as able to repel Wolverine's claws as a vibranium shield... and that didn't go so will with US Agent shield vs Adamantium Knife."
what srank said earlier
Originally posted by Wynndar
BP showed last time when he outmaneuvered Logan...he doesnt need vibranium weave cuz wolvie cant touch him...
He managed to grap Wolverine's arm an toss him, really not too impressive. Besides it was the only possible thing that could have happened considering that for some reason Wolverine charaged BP with his claws out and took a swipe at his head. Now Wolverine has meet Black Panther several times before and knows good an well who he is so why would he try to kill him? It is the only possible out come if Wolverine had landed his attack. Bad writing (not a shocker it was Hudlin after all) and an example of PIS if their ever was one. and why on earth was Gambit unable to avoid getting hit by Wolverine?
Even Wolverine sucker punching and pining BP during their team up is more relevent then what happened in Black Panther v4 8
I wouldn't call Hudlin's writing bad. He's just not totally deferring to the former writers ideas on the Black Panther character. Many writers have given their own views of characters and have been met with such, heavy handed criticisms. EX: Christopher Priest. Anyway, as for the issue. Black Panther #8. Where in the writing of that issue does it state Wolverine was attempting to kill Black Panther? For that matter where does it even show him attempting a killing move towards him? From my perspective it seemed as though Panther merely charged a virtually stationary Wolverine, Logan defensively swiped at him believing Panther was attacking, Panther parried and tossed him back. After-all, his goal was to keep THEM away from the guy who could absorb their powers, right? Where's the bad writing? That seems like a plausible reaction to me. Should Wolverine just STAND there and stare at an oncoming Panther? It's not like this was a one on one cage fight to the death. The Black Panther's goal wasn't to " defeat " the X-Men. It was to KEEP THEM AWAY from the guy who could absorb their powers.
Originally posted by nathan summers
I wouldn't call Hudlin's writing bad. He's just not totally deferring to the former writers ideas on the Black Panther character. Many writers have given their own views of characters and have been met with such, heavy handed criticisms. EX: Christopher Priest. Anyway, as for the issue. Black Panther #8. Where in the writing of that issue does it state Wolverine was attempting to kill Black Panther? For that matter where does it even show him attempting a killing move towards him? From my perspective it seemed as though Panther merely charged a virtually stationary Wolverine, Logan defensively swiped at him believing Panther was attacking, Panther parried and tossed him back. After-all, his goal was to keep THEM away from the guy who could absorb their powers, right? [b]Where's the bad writing? That seems like a plausible reaction to me. Should Wolverine just STAND there and stare at an oncoming Panther? It's not like this was a one on one cage fight to the death. The Black Panther's goal wasn't to " defeat " the X-Men. It was to KEEP THEM AWAY from the guy who could absorb their powers. [/B]
First panel of the page Wolverine is charaging at BP, in next panel BP rushes to meet him and then Wolverine swings at him and Black Panther uses Wolverine's momentum to launch him into the x-men. The narrative doesn't need to tell you that Wolverine was trying to kill BP it's easy enough to peace together since it's the only possible thing that could have happened if that attack hit him.
That seems to be your own personal interpretation of what occured in the panel and not exactly what was there. Yes, Wolverine charged forward, as did Rogue, Gambit, Iceman etc. They did so to clear the debri after the fact that Rogue blew the door in. It also seems Wolverine STOPPED for a moment when he made the statement " ...or the not-so-easy way. " At this point Panther charges towards a virtually stationary Wolverine, etc. There was hardly any over the top aggression on Wolverine's part. He wasn't out to " kill " Panther. If he was, he would have done a lot more than do some little swipe. And we would have seen more than a single panel of Wolverine getting tossed back into the group. You're over analyzing.