Anakins Vision

Yeah, we've had this discussion before haven't we? 😆

I always thought he just shouted, but closer examination, you don't need subtitles to hear that he acutally says "Never!" 😉

I like the idea of Obi-Wan holding a dead Padme...

If its not that, the only other thing I can see making any sense is if he sees maybe Palpatine shooting Force Lightning at Luke, or the Jedi that Windu takes with him to attack Palpatine. But then again...both of those would spoil that part of the movie...hm......it can't be Alderaan's destruction cause if that upset him then he wouldn't be pro-Death Star.....Maybe its a vision of something that has to do with the Sith..like that Darth Plagueis in hoods destroying Jedi in the temple, and he looks under the hood and the man is wearing Padme's necklace that Anakin made for her.....I don't know, this one is hard lol.

Does it have to be Anikan having the vision?, What if the eye scene from the trailer is part of a dream Padme or Obi-wan has. and I know you folks dont like the idea of a dream being inserted, however Lucas may do this not only for a nice shocking moment in the flick but also for a nice trailer shot 🙂

I think it should be Anakin having a vision. The force is attempting to tell him that he must be there to stop Palpatine with Mace. Of course, we all know that Anakin is too selfish...

perhaps the scene with mace fighting palpatine is anakins destiny point. he can kill the sith and rid them forever, or turn against the jedi and become a sith. anakin has two oppurtunities to rid the galaxy of the sith forever, this scene, and the scene in ROTJ when he finally kills palpatine.

[B]i really think he will have a vision of a grown luke and leia from the OT movies... that would be really cool to watch ...no?

"no...cause he had no idea about Leia in ROTJ. That would compramise that whole scene. I think it's more along the lines of him being the strongest in the galaxy, due in part to a mind trick from Palps. I dont think about him being evil, just people praising him, as far as the council and civilians."

but if he sees her older... how is he to recognize her as his daughter..first of all he probably doesn't think he is having a girl..second he hasn't seen her grown up.... so he still would not know who she is and besides even if he doesn't see Leia(which probably won't happen) there is a big chance he WILL see Luke...without knowing its Luke however

That's possible.

Originally posted by theshakl
[B]i really think he will have a vision of a grown luke and leia from the OT movies... that would be really cool to watch ...no?

"no...cause he had no idea about Leia in ROTJ. That would compramise that whole scene. I think it's more along the lines of him being the strongest in the galaxy, due in part to a mind trick from Palps. I dont think about him being evil, just people praising him, as far as the council and civilians."

but if he sees her older... how is he to recognize her as his daughter..first of all he probably doesn't think he is having a girl..second he hasn't seen her grown up.... so he still would not know who she is and besides even if he doesn't see Leia(which probably won't happen) there is a big chance he WILL see Luke...without knowing its Luke however

there is no way he is going to see leia. no way. ever. period.

lucas doesnt use flashbacks, so why use flashforwards? it has to be something relevant to ep3 near the end.

Vader (if you will remember from ROTJ) had no clue that Leia was his daughter. If he had a vision about Leia he would have known she was his spawn.

I agree, it has to be something Episode 3 related. Maybe it'll be a vision of himself as Vader after the duel with Obi-Wan. Since it's been said that Anakin isn't in the vision, and Vader isn't really Anakin, I think we have a good chance of seeing Vader in the vision. Sort of like a warning saying, "This is the path you're walking down, turn back." or something like that. I think that'd be pretty cool.

I see a lot of assuming that the vision will be something of the future, or what-not. As this was not the case in ESB- it was a metaphorical vision- do we actually have any reason to think that?

Originally posted by jedijunky1138
I think his vision is of lots of lava and extream pain. He may not see himself but he could see Vader. Anakin is no longer Anakin after he falls to the darkside. So a vison of Vader may not be considered a vision of himself.

True, I mean Luke was seeing something that was supposedly currently happening (if I'm thinking the same thing you are Ush) but really, we're all just speculating.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I see a lot of assuming that the vision will be something of the future, or what-not. As this was not the case in ESB- it was a metaphorical vision- do we actually have any reason to think that?

no reason to think it...other than it could happen.
when, before or after the dagobah scene did we see anything of the sort? that scene was way out of left field, and who's to say GL doesnt have any other tricks up his sleeve.

as far as my theory, its just that. a theory.

but if we only look to what GL has done but once as a frame of reference....its impossible. luke wasn't really in a dream...it was like more like a hallucination in a way, since he was physically in that cave and fighting with his weapon. although what he saw was not there, HE was there and the cave was real. however, with the exclusion of anakin from his own vision, its a totally different concept. its would be a complete dream sequence....so i think. nothing of the sort has ever been done is star wars.

you know what? maybe anakin has a "vision" dealing with his past. He would see all the events leading up to that point, and he might decide then whether to turn on the jedi/follow the ways of the sith.

i know its different than the other theories.....just my idea! 😉

Maybe. I heard a rumor at one point about something going back to Episode 1, which was in his past. But again, the vision is not of himself.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I see a lot of assuming that the vision will be something of the future, or what-not. As this was not the case in ESB- it was a metaphorical vision- do we actually have any reason to think that?

I quote from Jedi Priestess's thread concerning ROTS info:

"** Anakin does have a disturbing future vision in ROTS similar to Luke's cave test in TESB. But it is NOT of himself."

Note the word FUTURE in that sentence plzkthx. 💃 💃 💃

oh right. i forgot its not about him... 🙁

ok who wants to bet now that it is a vision of the future ..and by that i mean the OT

i stand with what i said earlier about padme and obiwan