Elektra vs. Buffy vs. Catwomen vs. Batgirl

Another bout of martial arts madness, this time involving four lasses who are skilled warriors and are remarkably adept in physical combat.

Once again this is an all out battle, with no prep-time, although the ring will be littered with a selection of weapons that should be suitable to any one of these contenders. So, which one is the greatest warrior girl alive?

Imperial, can I just watch all of them "get it on" instead? Must they fight?

Um, ok, I guess thats a valid option...

I don't care who wins as long as I get to watch

Now, I just want to make it clear that this match will not involve mud, nor jelly. However these warrior women might be ticked off by to much oogling, any opinion at all who might win? Although feel free to oogle.

Since, this is a fighting thread, my money is on..........hmm.....I'm going with Elektra. Maybe they can all be friends afterwards so I get to see the "real" show?

still I don't care but it would be good with mud

This is a battle between Elektra and Bagirl.
And if it is the Cassandra Cain Batgirl then the winner is pretty straightforward.
Batgirl wins.
Elektra is good, actually she is great, but Batgirl is just insane!

catwoman does have a whip.
elektra has sais aswell
I don't know what other weapons they'll have

Buffy has strength, durability, and stamina on them, but even at her best she does not seem to have the skills of the killer instinct of the others.

Catwoman probably has the most experience and the longest ranged melee weapon, but her durability and skill do not match that of Elektra and Bat Girl. Elektra has beat Catwoman and so has Bat Girl I think.

We then come to Bat Girl and Elektra. Given some of Elektra's recent accomplishment this is probably closer then I would have ever thought. While Bat Girl has beat the likes Batman and Shiva. Elektra has scored victories over Wolverine who can go toe to toe with the best fighters in the Marvel Universe. Elektra has Capatain America level durability and more fighting skills then Daredevil according to the Marvel Encyclopedia, but Bat Girl is considered to have meta-human level strength and speed. They both have similiar amounts of training and experience. I'll just say if this comic was written Bat Girl would win.

The other option is Buffy comes back to life and disappears until the end of the fight. At which point she returns having extensively researched her opponents. She also happens to be weilding the slayer scythe, Olath's hammer, and a set of orbs like Warren had. She also has a joining spell to connecting her to all the other slayers and scoobies. So she can either turn her opponents into doves or just beat them down whole sale. 🙂

Buffy has the durability on the other characters; here blunt force truma damage soak is insane but not strength. Her best strength feet was carrying an I-beam (I would imagine that is less then a ton) and she is only a bit stronger then Angel... who need the help of four others to carry a 1 ton casket. She is the first one out me thinks.

Poor Buffy. Wait a Minute. I think that Catwoman would go out first. She's experienced but not as skilled or as strong as the others. Overall, I think that Batgirl would dominate. The girl never loses a fight.

Elektra wins this one. She is much more skilled than Buffy or Catwoman. Only Batgirl comes close to her level, and I'd say Elektra has an edge on her.

No way would Elektra win. She's not as skilled as Batgirl.

Buffy is stupid, Elektra is a lesbian, Catwoman is...
Batgirl...

Uhhh... hmmm

Can Elektra still make illusions and stuff?

I wasnt aware she ever could.

No. She just has her sais and martial art skills. The Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe : DareDevil 2004 ranks her fighting skills as 5. Captain America is 7. Batgirl can defeat Captain America. Batgirl wins.

Batgirl can't defeat Cap but thats a different story

Why do you people buy those handbooks, its a rip off they update the heroes constantly so they can release new editions, and its all free on marvel.com