Thanos vs. Superman & Thor

Started by carver916 pages

Originally posted by -Pr-
1) how can you argue against blatant on panel statements? sticking your fingers in your ears and going "la la la i can't hear you" is not countering. that is trolling, you know.

2) why do you assume i care about thanos? uhuh

Lol...The thanos comment wasn't towards you.

As for doomsday... everyone has these types of hyperbole statements... its not that I'm ignoring it, its hyerbole and I just haven't seen any speed feats from doomsday to make me think otherwise.

Has the flash ever met or fought against doomsday?

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...The thanos comment wasn't towards you.

As for doomsday... everyone has these types of hyperbole statements... its not that I'm ignoring it, its hyerbole and I just haven't seen any speed feats from doomsday to make me think otherwise.

Has the flash ever met or fought against doomsday?

what hyperbole statements? i really hope you're not talking about booster gold, as i wasn't using him at all.

yes, during doomsday wars. in fact, the entire jla did.

as to how i saw your post, well: i saw a superman thread with you as the last poster, and knew i was just bound to see some lowballing going on.

current thanos should win a comfortable majority.

👆

Originally posted by Power Cosmic II
current thanos should win a comfortable majority.

I agree with current thanos winning (he is a beast) but classic... hell no.

Originally posted by carver9
I agree with current thanos winning (he is a beast) but classic... hell no.
Originally posted by Nihilist
Thanos stalemated Thor w/power gem who destroyed Adam Warlock Surfer and Dr Strange together(3 high heralds), so he doesnt have to have them kind of showing.

You show me WWH doing the same, yet you claim he could without having feats like that to back it up.

Stop avoiding.

Originally posted by Nihilist
Stop avoiding.

That power gem thor vs thanos fight wasn't even long enough for us to use the type of abc logic that you are using. How many punchesb were thrown that fight... four to five?

Then he resorted to a plot and I never said that either of them would win a majority against thanos but again... either could give him trouble alone.

Supes feat alone tell us that he could give thanos a run for his money... thor feats alone tell us the same and that is what you are ignoring.

Originally posted by carver9
That power gem thor vs thanos fight wasn't even long enough for us to use the type of abc logic that you are using. How many punchesb were thrown that fight... four to five?

Then he resorted to a plot and I never said that either of them would win a majority against thanos but again... either could give him trouble alone.

Supes feat alone tell us that he could give thanos a run for his money... thor feats alone tell us the same and that is what you are ignoring.

No, you are ignoring Thor destroying Adam Warlock, Surfer, Strange plus another 3-4 people at once and Thanos matching him blow for blow(Thanos got more hits in and Blasts as well] plus this Thors striking power and durability is far above Supermans and regular Thors.

Super/Thor feats dont tell us the could give Thanos a fight, when Thanos feats tell us he beats Surfer/Thor lvl guys with little fuss and takes skyfather lvl attacks on a regular and is able to fight on.

Originally posted by h1a8
Fail. You forget Thanos can't tank neither punches with a smile.

Comic fights hold no water if they contradict what would really happen in a forum fight. Character's often are found not fighting at their best, not using their best speed and skills etc.

Hulk tagging Surfer doesn't mean Hulk has ftl reflexes and speed. It just means Surfer didn't fight to his best ability as shown before.

Yes he can.Power gem thor with mjolnir whos strikes are much stronger then supermans he tanked with a smile.
Originally posted by h1a8
That's not my definition of tank. My definition of tank is to not be stunned nor damaged in any way.

Thanos face was bloody and he was getting rocked (momentarily stunned) by Thor's blows. Thor wasn't amped much by the power gem. He was more amp due to not holding back.

Superman can stun Thanos with his blows and Superman is fast enough to chain blows fast enough to prevent Thanos from coming out of the stun state (the stun will be renewed for each blow).

Superman alone beats Thanos. This fight is spite. Don't mess with me.

He was only bloodly because glass cut him.Not thor.

Except he can tank his punches.He will barley feel them.

Thanos grabs the hero boys and BONK`s their heads together for the quick win.

Originally posted by chomperx9
Thanos didnt tank mjolnir here
Not what we are talking about...
Originally posted by Nihilist
Thanos stalemated Thor w/power gem who destroyed Adam Warlock Surfer and Dr Strange together, so he doesnt have to have them kind of showing.

You show me WWH doing the same, yet you claim he could without having feats like that to back it up.

Honestly B&T was filled with PIS cuz he shouldn't have beaten that group.

Originally posted by carver9
I agree with current thanos winning (he is a beast) but classic... hell no.
Class might, might lose if we are talking pre-death.But he can still win.

Originally posted by Nihilist
No, you are ignoring Thor destroying Adam Warlock, Surfer, Strange plus another 3-4 people at once and Thanos matching him blow for blow(Thanos got more hits in and Blasts as well] plus this Thors striking power and durability is far above Supermans and regular Thors.

Super/Thor feats dont tell us the could give Thanos a fight, when Thanos feats tell us he beats Surfer/Thor lvl guys with little fuss and takes skyfather lvl attacks on a regular and is able to fight on.

And that's the reason I would give thanos the majority against either superman or thor "alone". Thanos did good against power gem thor but it was more of a durability showing than anything else. That's what thanos is famous for... taking an ass whiipin without falling but again... I can't see him taking these two together because he doesn't have the feats.

Your abc logic isn't proving this. Show me him fighting two opponents of this caliber and stomping them.

By the way, thanos defeated classic surfer, a surfer that isn't even comparable to current surfer and let's not forget that thanos fleed when surfer was shooting blast so powerful that it was creating enormous black holes in space.

Originally posted by carver9
And that's the reason I would give thanos the majority against either superman or thor "alone". Thanos did good against power gem thor but it was more of a durability showing than anything else. That's what thanos is famous for... taking an ass whiipin without falling but again... I can't see him taking these two together because he doesn't have the feats.

Your abc logic isn't proving this. Show me him fighting two opponents of this caliber and stomping them.

By the way, thanos defeated classic surfer, a surfer that isn't even comparable to current surfer and let's not forget that thanos fleed when surfer was shooting blast so powerful that it was creating enormous black holes in space.

He was fleeing from the black holes...not surfer.And by the way he could tank them.classic surfer flew through black holes with ease.Current thanos's durability>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>his then.

Originally posted by carver9
And that's the reason I would give thanos the majority against either superman or thor "alone". Thanos did good against power gem thor but it was more of a durability showing than anything else. That's what thanos is famous for... taking an ass whiipin without falling but again... I can't see him taking these two together because he doesn't have the feats.

Your abc logic isn't proving this. Show me him fighting two opponents of this caliber and stomping them.

By the way, thanos defeated classic surfer, a surfer that isn't even comparable to current surfer and let's not forget that thanos fleed when surfer was shooting blast so powerful that it was creating enormous black holes in space.

Feats.. he can physically punch Surfer lvl guys to death, in a weaker pre death form he can floor Thor with just a eye blast and he can tank skyfather lvl hits far beyond(Odin,Tyrant,Maker,Walker) anything Supes/Thor can do together.

LOL, he doesnt have to fight two heralds to show he could beat them in a forum match up, show me WWH beating 2 mid herlads at once or Galactus beating 2 skyfathers at once, Thanos crushed Surfer(Marvels highest high herald) with ease simply stacking heralds doesnt do anything.

Current Surfer is the same as classic Surfer as confirmed by Editor Tom Breevort, his power up is a fallacy.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Honestly B&T was filled with PIS cuz he shouldn't have beaten that group.
Why was it pis? because you dont agree with it.

Reg Thor was on the lvl with anybody he fought in that arc, the gem put him over anyone he faced due to his increased power,durabilty,stamina etc.

Originally posted by carver9
Show me a speed feat from Doomsday besides a hyperbole statement that every character have under their belt. Doomsday doesnt have a legitimate speed feat under his belt... hell, if we look at speed feats, hulk outshines Doomsday.

The same hyperbole statement that Doomsday receive, hundreds of other bricks received the same thing.

Doomsdays speed is nothing but a myth or fans dream.

Carver, you've been shown the scans before. Gardner, Booster and Supes all commented on DD's speed. Just stop now.

Originally posted by Nihilist
Why was it pis? because you dont agree with it.

Reg Thor was on the lvl with anybody he fought in that arc, the gem put him over anyone he faced due to his increased power,durabilty,stamina etc.

Honestly the watch + maxam + strange should have been able to beat or at least subdue thor.And your saying that thor just hammering the gem out of draxs stomach isn't PIS?I don't really believe anything involving thanos was PIS.Although had the match been going longer he would have lost.Power gem works that way.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Honestly the watch + maxam + strange should have been able to beat or at least subdue thor.And your saying that thor just hammering the gem out of draxs stomach isn't PIS?I don't really believe anything involving thanos was PIS.Although had the match been going longer he would have lost.Power gem works that way.
Apart from Drax's gem thing nothing was pis,which isnt part of the battle when Thor had the gem, as they couldnt beat Thor down as he was far too durable, and he reversed Strange/Warlock best attack.

Superman Sundips a
then uses TVO as Thor unlead
ses the GODBLAST 101011000010101010! 😛