Episode 3 is going to suck

Yeah I agree that GL has at times sacrificed character development for action scenes but that doesnt mean it sucks. I personally LOVE the new saber battle techniques, looks so much better. And I cant wait for this new space battle, although I think I'm gonna have to see it 50 times just to figure out who is who.... But gimme a break, we come here to talk about SW because we LOVE SW & then you're surprised when folks dont play nice? Its like saying your kid is ugly right to your face, some things are just rude. The whole saga has its problems but you know what? Thats why we are all still here...Had it all been wrapped up nicely with no lingering questions the interest would have died out years ago... So no matter what I still love SW and still expect to be blown away by ROTS.

Originally posted by shockimebones
Episode 3 is gonna suck

errrrrrrrrrrr NO

people have there own oppinions but personaly i think we shouldnt judge a movie till we see it.

Originally posted by bilbofett
Yeah I agree that GL has at times sacrificed character development for action scenes but that doesnt mean it sucks. I personally LOVE the new saber battle techniques, looks so much better. And I cant wait for this new space battle, although I think I'm gonna have to see it 50 times just to figure out who is who.... But gimme a break, we come here to talk about SW because we LOVE SW & then you're surprised when folks dont play nice? Its like saying your kid is ugly right to your face, some things are just rude. The whole saga has its problems but you know what? Thats why we are all still here...Had it all been wrapped up nicely with no lingering questions the interest would have died out years ago... So no matter what I still love SW and still expect to be blown away by ROTS.

When did I imply that I was "surprised" by people's reactions to my post? I fully expected people here to have an overly optimistic view towards Episode 3 and thus disagree with my opinions, not that I made the post as a way of inciting arguments or anything. I'm happy for you people that you're so excited for this film, but sometimes you have to be realistic, and realistically Lucas won't be able to pull this off successfully. Not only because of the reasons I already mentioned, but because this is the final Star Wars movie, or at least is to be presumed to be. Therefore the media will be hyping it up to a huge degree, making articles asking the question as to how will Lucas end the saga, how will he fuse the prequel trilogy with the classic trilogy, will he make up for the poor mistakes he made on the previous prequels, and so on. Everyone will be asking these questions, waiting for this final installment of one of the most successful and popular series of all time, and you really think that under all this pressure George Lucas, a 60-year-old man who cannot write a decent script even with the aid of a 2nd writer, will make this film work?

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
errrrrrrrrrrr NO

What an insightful reply you've given. I don't know what to say, you've just totally out-witted me glare

how episode 3 going to suck. it can't because its got a best story of any star wars movies. In this movie Lucas will show his full potential which he held back in 2 other films. Josh said that the acting was lot better.
They is no way it going to suck. Only reason the two other matrix were
not that good because it wasn't a good story which episode 3 will have.
close this thread he doesn't know what he's talking about.

Originally posted by shockimebones
What an insightful reply you've given. I don't know what to say, you've just totally out-witted me glare

doesnt someone have a chip on their shoulder.
hey, i have a GREAT idea! check this out:

why dont we all wait till we actually SEE episode3 before we critique it!!! 😱

<insert "insightful reply" here>

cornponious

I know episode 3 will be the best star wars movie because all the pics,
all spoilers, all the reviews by josh , all infro from Nick, all the webdocs,
all the set pics and even supershadow said it will be the best and the moment we be waiting for the birth of Darth vader. I have complete faith
in Lucas.

You had to go and bring Supershadow into it, didn't you?

😉

corn

Originally posted by izz316
I know episode 3 will be the best star wars movie because all the pics,
all spoilers, all the reviews by josh , all infro from Nick, all the webdocs,
all the set pics and even supershadow said it will be the best and the moment we be waiting for the birth of Darth vader. I have complete faith
in Lucas.

ROTFLMFAO! SUPERSHADOW! 😆 😆 😱 😱

I say wait for May before u say that ROTS sucks or rocks.

Wow, SS said this would be the best? Hey NOW its official!!!

Episode 3 will be the best hands down and I don't know why some people knock episode 1 and 2? ok episode I was a little weak but still good, but episode 2 was incredible it brought all the elements together on what is to come in episode 3, the transformation of Anakin and the destruction of the Republic making episode 3 by far the best!

Don't knock the movie until you see it

To the guy who made this thread, I understand where he's coming from. But don't let all the little details of the story spoil the movie for ya when you see it. Okay so there is going to be some things a little out of proportion, but if you really want to like it, do three things...

1. Sit Down
2. Shut Up
3. Enjoy the Movie

Shockimebones, Fair play that you note that GL might not be able to write a decent script but he wrote ANH,-granted a long time ago,- and that worked in part because of the plot/characters. He improved things bringing in Kasdan for TESB and ROTJ and they were cool enough weren't they...? True, the greatest of all script writers he might not be, but he could bring out the depth of character development despite this.

Besides which, I remember him saying that he saw the saga as firstly visual, then the sound/music THEN the words..... That seems to have been good enough for most fans (Maybe with the possible exception of TPM) maybe the advancement in quality from TPM to AOTC will follow through to ROTS..?

I agree that most of your concerns are valid, but we aren't waiting for a screen interpretation of Henry the 8th here, are we...? As long as the questions/scenarios set up in Eps 1&2 are rounded off, the wraparound to Ep4 executed well and finally it maintain energy and tension throughout, then won't it still rock....?

Don't torture yourself tooooo much over it.
It means the world to us too and for sure, this thread is a valid one, but accept that other posters may have a point and feel appeased by that from time to time... We aren't actually having a go or anything by posting an opposing view y'know...! 🙂
Well, for what it's worth I hope that on May 19th the movie meets your better expectations anyway... and that you do find it enjoyable..
Peace 🙂

spiderman is one of the best, well done comic to movie adaptations ever made. [/B][/QUOTE]

actually man-spider "which is what it SHOULD have been called",is about the worst comic to movie adaptations ever made. 😠 🙄

as all true fans know,that movie totally betrayed and butchered his character to death. 😠 😠 😠 🙄

erm...am i in the right forum?

ROTS is gonna be great! what is wrong with you shockimebones!!!

This thread ranks alongside Oriental lady looking for love! lame! weak! 😒