Should Emma Frost Stay With Cyclops?

Started by thedarkphoenix16 pages

no because is going to come back AGAIN cause the phoneix and jean are one. and scott will come running back to jean as always! ✅

sorry i meant to put jean in that 😮

Can't they just let her stay dead? Her story is convoluted enough as it is.

i doubt it

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Can't they just let her stay dead? Her story is convoluted enough as it is.
I would like to see her dead for the next five to ten years too!
Using her every now and then makes the whole Phoenix-line less special and less interesting imo...she/it deserves better!!!

Btw...I think Emma and Scott make up a great couple!
Scott and Jean were sooo fifties/sixties...the strong, capable, emotion suppressing (and thus manly) Leader and his beautiful, yet decent, slightly motherly and supporting wife...😘
Emma as a leader is as strong as Scott, is not afraid to argue with him and stand her ground, truly loves him and, most important, is loved in return by a Scott who doesn't feel the need to be afraid of sharing his emotions and desires with her, something he could not do with his either allmighty, evil or dead wife!
Emma might play the Bad Girl in front of the world, but when it comes to her relationship with Scott, she is quite caring and open and Scott knows what's behind the mask. It was this openness without shame, and i don't mean just the sexual side, that made him fall for Emma...my blessing!

I hate Emma as co- head of the school. She doesnt deserve it. Just because she is f-ing Scott doesnt mean she should co-head the school. That has always p*ssed me off. Its like saying if I was having s*x with Scott I should be the co-head.

NICOLE! u potty mouth lol it's true though she shouldn't be co-head it was the White Queen u know

im aloud to have a potty mouth but ur not since u are still young..lol

Originally posted by crimsonphoenix
I hate Emma as co- head of the school. She doesnt deserve it. Just because she is f-ing Scott doesnt mean she should co-head the school. That has always p*ssed me off. Its like saying if I was having s*x with Scott I should be the co-head.
😬 How about the fact that she's the only one of the Astonishing X-Men whose actually trained to be a teacher? And that she's been the Headmistress of schools before?

look how that turn out.......dead students. And she is just not co-head in Astonishing,she is also co-head in uncanny. Trained or not she doesnt deserve the position of co-head.

Originally posted by crimsonphoenix
look how that turn out.......dead students. And she is just not co-head in Astonishing,she is also co-head in uncanny. Trained or not she doesnt deserve the position of co-head.
And how often did the X-mansion get destroyed and pupils hurt and even killed (Thunderbird1, Quentin, Sophie, that gaseous kid from Xorn's special class) under Xavier and Scott???
When you're teaching a viciously hated minority of people with super powers, such tragedies are ALMOST INEVITABLE.

So what makes you think Emma, the only trained teacher of the X-Men, does not deserve her position APART from your dislike for her character?!

Every one of the X-Men has chequered parts to their past. Emma is actually the most qualified in terms of teacher training - she has studied Education with a minor in Business - which positions her perfectly for the a role of teacher and administrator at the Xavier Institute. Add to that - the power of telepathy is well suited for the role of teacher and Headmistress.
Thing is she genuinely loves teaching and she genuinely cares for her students. And if you're going to have a teacher - that's the best kind there is.

These pretty much should be the core characteristics for a teacher!!! ✅ (Btw...i'm in my last year at university to become a teacher myself.)

i never said i didn't like Emma i just said she doesn't deserve being co-head. yes she cares 4 her students but she wants them to be like her. example: the stepford cuckoos.... And i dont think its a good idea to have a speech that contains "They will always hate us".

and also doesnt say anywhere she has a teaching degree. so your asuming that she haves one cuz she was headmistress of the hellions. scott doesnt have a teaching degree .
here is a link to emmas profile....

http://www.mutanthigh.com/emma.html

Originally posted by crimsonphoenix
i never said i didn't like Emma i just said she doesn't deserve being co-head. yes she cares 4 her students but she wants them to be like her. example: the stepford cuckoos.... And i dont think its a good idea to have a speech that contains "They will always hate us".
Maybe, but nonetheless she knows about the parts of herself that are "un-x-menish" and seeks for others to compensate for that (Shadowcat, Moonstar)...remarkable expression of selfreflection.
Additionally she teaches the students to develop strong personalities who can decide for themselves, which behaviour is appropriate and which not (the mentioned cuckoos for example).
From an (almost) professional point of view she is actually quite good and certainly much better than a character whose only qualification is being a mutant!

Originally posted by crimsonphoenix
and also doesnt say anywhere she has a teaching degree. so your asuming that she haves one cuz she was headmistress of the hellions. scott doesnt have a teaching degree .
here is a link to emmas profile....

http://www.mutanthigh.com/emma.html

You and this file are not up to date...read Emma Frost's own 18 issue series!

i wouldnt care if she was a regular teacher but as for co -head she hasnt (in my eyes) earned that yet. In the near future maybe. Now asuming jean comes back and takes on the role even if she wasnt with scott the Jean gets the co-head role.

Well then i take it back...she does have a teaching degree but im still standing strong on thinking she doesnt deserve it.

Lets look on the upside of things. You and i both think she should teach! And im not up to date on Emma Frost ( cuz i dont read her series). I hope after wut i said we can become friends and get pass this issue.