Will Episode III surpass any of the OT movies? [Merged]

So.. we've still got a few smart people around. That's good to know.

I believe we should close this thread. I think those hardcore new Star Wars fans can create their own thread, where they can agree with each other that the new Star Wars films are better...MacGeek, stop trying to keep the thread going for no reason. There's nothing more to discuss.

yeah we should probably close it. the point of it was to find out what percent of the people think it will be the greatest star wars movie. and the answer is 70%. So that's all I really wanted to get out of this thread. It can be closed.

Because it consists mostly of new fans not old.

Originally posted by hunchy
Because it consists mostly of new fans not old.

Sad but true

Yep unfortunatley 🙁

Not every new fan thinks the PT is better than the OT *raises hand*

TIMMEH!!!!

Funny, I thought TPM and AOTC surpassed the OT. 😬

Originally posted by Sith Master X
Funny, I thought TPM and AOTC surpassed the OT. 😬

Glad there's a few old fans...and I think the old effects are better than CG.

^ yup, absolutely

More creative, that's for sure. But not better.

Originally posted by LandoSpeeder2
In technology 😛

Yep, in technology, action and story. p

Yes, more creative fx and yes better. especially the old models they use to use for ships...far superior.

The OT had a far better story as well. If your looking for action, sure the PT is whats for you...but the originals weren't about that. They actually had great dialouge (cough cough unlike AOTC cough cough).

Originally posted by macgeek2005
More creative, that's for sure. But not better.

If you still think the PT effects are better after looking at these... I really don't know what's wrong with you... of course you really have to see them in motion to get the full effect.

I bow down to you Dodo. Look how cartoony the new Star Wars stuff is, and how dark, gritty, and great looking the OT shots are. Look how superior and detailed the Yoda puppet is, and how cartoony and childish the CG Yoda is.

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
If you still think the PT effects are better after looking at these... I really don't know what's wrong with you... of course you really have to see them in motion to get the full effect.

haha you can see in the countdokuu pic that his cape is atached to strings,look 😛

We all got our own opinions. I think the OT animation is great, but if anything looks more cartoony it's the OT "in my opinion."