no no no no lets try that again
Fightingwise i will give that to squall
Appearance is tidus all the way
Personality there is no way in hell the that squall would have that over tidus
the story line is waaaaaaaay better in ffx
Characters no way there is tidus, Yuna, wakka, lulu Rikku hell no ff8 had anything over it
All in all Tidus is the Man!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 💃 😍 😎
As characters, I must go with Squall. Why? His personality is much deeper than that of Tidus's. Tidus is a whiny jock. And sure, jocks can love too. It seems that Tidus has a good heart and everything, which is all nice when said and done, but Squall's personality is much deeper. When playing each game, you obviously have to learn about the characters. With Tidus, you immediately can tell that his personality is that of a stereotype, already. A do-gooder jock who falls in love with the woman who is going to die to save the world. Tragic, yes. But Squall; he starts off battling his nemesis, who ends up becoming an agent of evil very early into the game. Squall seems heartless at first, and obviously is a loner. But why? You have to play the game to actually find out.
Rinoa comes in on a mission, he doesn't expect to fall in love with her, so he doesn't. He tries to push her away, because there's something more to him that makes him not want to get into a relationship with her. Tidus is just full-blown hornball and wants to get closer to her, and he eventually does. There's no fun in that, plus it was hardly as entertaining or rewarding as controlling Squall was. Squall had been an orphan, and his past comes back to him. To haunt, or to confront? Who knows. You still have to keep playing to uncover more about Squall. Even with Tidus, the plot twist that Sin is Jecht, that comes very, very early on. Too early, I think.
X's story might have made more sense to some people, and may be better. VIII's story was a bit confusing, I'll give it that. But this debate isn't about the story, it's about the characters. I think Squall had more to offer, gameplay-wise, and personality-wise. And if they fought, Squall could shoot Tidus before he ripped him to shreads with his gunblade.
Kenshinswife, you offer no argument for Tidus, other than a fangirl's "Ooh, squee, I love Tidus!" Appearence hardly has to do anything with the factor in choosing the better character. But if that's what you're into, Tidus's pants also sucked. They were half-cut on one side, lopsided and uneven. Squall's black attire and gunblade definately makes him look much more badass.
Originally posted by KenshinswifeNo, I don't think. There is not always a character that's mysterious. Sometimes, yes, there is. But that character is better, because as your knowledge of the character grows, the character usually grows as well. Squall's story, past and present, were executed near-perfectly.
okay lets get something staraight....you can find a chracter like squall in every game dont you think? There is always a character(i could have sworn i said this before) like him.."Mysterious" with some type of Bad
With X-2, Tidus should have stayed dead. Technically, he still IS dead, but he's in a tangible form. X-2 ruined the tragic ending of X, while we're on the subject.
Originally posted by Draco69Not necessarily. But Tidus was a poorly conceived one, so yes, some video gamers don't like Tidus.
Like I said before Video gamers do not like jocks. Jocks and video gamers do not and will never mix.
sorry i didnt finish what i was saying...okay lets get something staraight....you can find a chracter like squall in every game dont you think? There is always a character(i could have sworn i said this before) like him.."Mysterious" with some type of Bad past that keeps him from loving or letting anyone in....I mean come on in every anime or in most games....there is always one....but so what Life goes on! Second, Your making me sound like i am being artificial and i am not...Yes squall would probably kick TIDUS ASS NO DOUBT ABOUT IT (maybe a little) but that doesnt make him a better character...Tidus may be a jock and whatever but so what! You automtically judge him because of that..and thats not fair! Tidus was just a deep as squall but he had a diffrent way of dealing with it...and he was not a hornball...he could have gotten any girl he wanted...but he chose Yuna because she was the most like him and she understood and tidus likewise...Yes i think Tidus is cute, but that doesnt change the way i feel about him as a character....
Originally posted by KenshinswifeI don't understand how a jacket can look homosexual. Are you 12? 😕
Who cares if he's a jock or not....a person is a person regaurdless and if thats the case you are stereotyping.....
FYI: Tidus pants are way cool
Squalls jacket looks gay with that pathetic fluff on top
...and he was not a hornball...he could have gotten any girl he wanted...but he chose YunaNot a hornball at all...
I hardly talked about them fighting each other, though it seems all you care about is clothes, looks, and fighting. You say that I'm stereotyping, well it's hard to stereotype when he IS one. And a whiny, annoying one at that. I CAN say that, because I have played through both games several times, and feel that Squall has a much deeper personality than Tidus.