Yah, Doom 3's atmosphere and graphics are fantastic. The human models do look kinda of wierd but other than that, it looks fantastic.
The enemy design is the best in any game, bar none and the sound is fantastic also. But other than that the game is stale.
ANd it ispretty scary also, but not as scary as Alien Vs Predator 2.
I think it is.
Doom 3 is scary at the start of the game. But midway through, it gets boring because you've seen all it has to offer.
AVP2, while dated compared to Doom 3. Is scary while playing the human campaign. Nothing beats walking aronud in the alien hive, hearing your motion tracker, seeing and hearing the eggs come apart with face huggers, and seeing them come out of the eggs. And the oh crap stage when a facehugger jumps on your face.
I find it more scary than Doom 3. But Doom 3 is still pretty scary also;.
But in the game, anything disrupts the motion tracker. So it can be anything. I find it panicky which I dont like, which makes it alot more scarier to me. Its not scary when you have no idea whats coming. You can startled when something jumps out but its not fear, its shock.
In AVP, the motion tracker is going off, you know something is in that room and you have to go through it. I find that scary as shit because your checking your back, moviing around, shining the light in tight spaces. Also, the motion stops working when no motion is happening.