Originally posted by Adam_PoE
God created a world without sin and Adam and Eve without knowledge of good and evil. If Eve had no knowledge of good and evil or right and wrong, how can she punished? If I put a three year old child in a room with a knife and told him not to play with it, should I be surprised when he does or punish him when he hurts himself as the result of my own negligence?
the child wouldnt take advantage of it... adam and eve did... they knew after whats good and evil (i think they also didnt knew before what sex is....)... so you cant compare these i think....
the point is... if the child hurts himself with a knife once. he wont do it again. if you punish him, it wouldnt change anything about the childs behaviour.
if the child eats a chocolate though you have forbidden it and it likes the taste of chocolate, it would do it again and again. if you punish him immediatly after he ate the chocolate he wont probably do it again... (not to discuss wether its the right way of child-care or not)
thats like the forbidden fruit thing....