Rouge vs. Hulk

As did Trauma.

"One touch is all she requires. She already beat him. Contest of Champions (2nd series) #5"

As stated, while the Contest of Champions is referable, hardly accurate.

One touch is all she needs? Ok so she touches him. Then what? Two things can happen:

A) She dies.

B) She becomes powered.

In the event of B, what happens? Punches Hulk around a bit.

Hulk will have compensated for the power he lost when she drained him almost immediately after she takes it.

Can She-Hulk beat Hulk? No. Rogue is essentially just gonna be a flying version of her. In which case, Rogue would need to win by beating Hulk up, since that's all she's got going for her. Which is never ever going to happen.

Don't see why this is even being discussed.

-AC

"As stated, while the Contest of Champions is referable, hardly accurate."

The battles were fanvoted. The story itself is prewritten by Chris Claramont before the battle outcomes are determined. The winners were all transported to an alien stadium. Brood Queen (possessing Rogue's body) absorbed all the winners powers in order to take over the universe (how original). Rogue administered ONE touch to the Hulk. And he fell in two seconds flat. The battle happened whether anybody likes it or not.

"A) She dies."

If she can absorb uber-powerful adversaries like Thor, Juggernaut, Magneto, Mephisto, and Scarlet Witch without ill effect then the Hulk would not be a problem. The gamma radiation won't kill her since she already absorbed She-Hulk, who is also gamma-irradiated, without ill effect.

"B) She becomes powered.

In the event of B, what happens? Punches Hulk around a bit."

And for each punch she administers she grows stronger and stronger. When the Hulk hits Rogue back she still grows stronger since his bare fist is connecting with her bare skin.

The transfer is instantenous. Rogue is not a leech that suckles bits and pieces of power. She's a vampire draining every drop of power her opponent has.

That comic was nonsense though. It's barely relevant to anything. It was quite literally a vehicle to resurrect an old unfinished story, if I remember rightly.

The battles were nonsense. (Wolverine beating Hercules?! With bone claws no less?!) They were fanvoted on Marvel.com. The story was already written.

Yes, so the outcome is fan determined, regardless of the pre-written story.

Actually the outcome was NOT fan determined. Rogue didn't participate in any of the battles or the actual contest itself. Claramont intended for Rogue to be possessed by the Brood. There were two different battles : story important ones and the . The fans only voted for the background battles. The story important ones were determined by Claramont. That's why we had rational battle outcomes (i.e. Iron Man vs. Psylocke) and irrational battles (i.e. Black Widow vs Wonder Man). The battles ( in terms of who was facing who) were already predetermined. So the artist just drew two seperate occasions for the two contestants. The Hulk was facing very easy opponents: Deadpool, Mr Fantastic, etc. Chris Claramont intended him to go to the end for story purposes.

That's right. So Rogue could drain his power. In fact it wasn't even Rogue, it was Rogue's power being used by someone else.

I don't think means to an ends, crossover plot devices are that relevant to what would actually happen in this fight.

It WAS Rogue's power. Brood Queen disguised herself as an attractive male so that Rogue would touch her. She dominated Rogue's mind and used her body.

Chris Claramont is readily showing signs of dementia. He should really retire.

Yeah it was Rogue's power. It wasn't Rogue though, that's why I don't think it's that relevant to the fight between Rogue and Hulk, especially when not written by that *writer*.

*shrugs*

Rogue. I agree with Draco69's summarization of the fight; yet would like to add that every time she absorbs him she not only grows stronger, but Hulk grows weaker.

Eventually, she'll grow much stronger than him, while his strength remains at a constant level due to being drained of strength and increase of strength by his rage.

His strength will only increase more.

He will have compensated by that time.

She can't drain enough from Hulk to actually make him weak, she'd kill herself.

-AC

Kill herself or flip out from all the power she's absorbing, along with all the rage from Hulk.

hmm.. good point.
but rogue could do with the ms. marvel power. and she could absorb it slowily

so really shed just be stealing a little bit of his extra strength. She'd get boosted up to, oh 140ton level in the fight but hulks 100 ton level should protect him till he compensates. I like when Rogues power is stream lined and she keeps her own body shape and size, not characteristics. I think she looks hot like that. When she fought Juggernaut, she couldn't absorb anymore, she hit her wall before he even noticed. And she didn't turn into a really big Howdy due de.
It'd be neat to see her fight the Hulk for the X-men. I think these guys might put her out of action permanently. If she faced someone like Colossus's strength she could get walloped and turn around and keep coming back. Juggs. and Hulk may not be so easy 🐰

For the sake of a forum, this thread is still going.

It shouldn't have been created. Come on. I mean, Hulk fan or Hulk hater....IT'S ROGUE VS HULK.

She is never ever going to win.

-AC

if betty ross can calm the hulk I don't think theres anny reason why rogue couldn't

Maybe because he loved/loves Betty, she was his wife, true love and one of the very few if not only person that understood him.

Who's Rogue to the Hulk? Nobody.

This isn't about who can sing a lullaby. It's Rogue Vs Hulk in a fight, in which Rogue would be dead. Drain or no drain. Stupid thread.

-AC

oh yeah well she coud try flurting

Rogue would steal Hulk's power and he'd drop like a stone. Even if she didn't put him out completely with one touch, with her flight and speed advantage she'd K.O. him pretty quickly.