Originally posted by The Inkeeper
disapointing? He had a big flaming sword 😕
He tells Gandalf hes going to kill him!Gandalf didnt fight him because 'no man can kill him' and as far as i can tell, Gandafl is a man. Plus, he didnt have one of those sexy noldor swords.
well sed i dont think id fite or even attempt to fite someone with a swordlike that ....
Gandalf is far more powerfull them witch king
The guy that wrote that scene in the EE of ROTK was drunk, he dont know nothing about the real story of JRRT. Look, to begin with, Gandalf defeated a Balrog! A Balrog is far more powerfull them the little witch king (that was only a men before), and Gandalf defeated him when he was grey, imagine what he could do now that he is white.
About the part that said that no men could ever kill him: it is just a profecy or something like it, and tolkien like to write things like that in his books (if you guys realy understand about LOTR you should know that!). That doesent mean that Gandalf couldnt kill him even if he try to, it means that was suposed to be woman, and it was, and if a woman could kill him them Gandalf could turn him into ashes.
In the book, I belive you have read it, Gandalf and witch king just look to each other, nothing else! Or Gandalf would kill him right away, it would be far more easy then a Balrog!
In the Return of The King book, when Sauron was looking to everyone, only Gandalf was imponent beyond his eyes. (only Gandalf!)
In the first book TOLKIEN wrote that Gandalf would become like the dark lord himself if he take the ring, so, logicaly, Gandalf is powerfull enough to Defeat Sauron if he dont wear the ring, and Gandalf would certainly defeat him after he became white, because Tolkien wrote in his book ( you just have to read it) that no power on earth could hurt him, and that leads to Gandalf x witch king, the "powerfull" witch king could never, ever have hurted him like he did on the movie!
Oh and there is one more thing, Gandalf is a Maiar for Cryst Sake, there is no way the witch king is more powerful then Gandalf, he was only a man before, and Gandalf was an acient spirit, older then the earth, more powerfull them all other races (especialy dark spirits corrupted by Sauron) just the Valars where more powerfull them the maiars!
To finish this I want to say that you guys that think the witch king is more powerful than Gandalf (hehe)...go to hell and stay there forever, you are not real fans of TLOTR and dont have to put your opinions about something you have saw in a movie. Think with me guys: Wich King can defeat Gandalf, but Gandalf is a Maiar, Sauron is a Maiar as well, Hmm...
so witch king is strong enouth to destroy Sauron? Hmm... I DONT THINK SO!!!!! You guys are nutts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If you were as big a book fan as you say you are, you will have noted that the significant blow was struck by Merry- a Hobbit, not a Man- not by Eowyn.
Only Merry was carrying a weapon that could hurt the Witch-King.
(that's not true; so was Aragorn, but the point still remains).
What the Witch-King was before is irrelevant; he is a very potent threat indeed and Tolkien clearly builds him up as one, even compared to Gandalf.
Re: Gandalf is far more powerfull them witch king
Originally posted by Gandalfjon
The guy that wrote that scene in the EE of ROTK was drunk, he dont know nothing about the real story of JRRT. Look, to begin with, Gandalf defeated a Balrog! A Balrog is far more powerfull them the little witch kingnNot true (that was only a men before), and Gandalf defeated him when he was grey, imagine what he could do now that he is white.About the part that said that no men could ever kill him: it is just a profecy or something like it, and tolkien like to write things like that in his books (if you guys realy understand about LOTR you should know that!). That doesent mean that Gandalf couldnt kill him even if he try to, it means that was suposed to be woman, and it was, and if a woman could kill him them Gandalf could turn him into ashes. How sexist, and i disagree
In the book, I belive you have read it, Gandalf and witch king just look to each other, nothing else! Or Gandalf would kill him right away, it would be far more easy then a Balrog! Yet again not true, otherwise Gandalf would have killed him and saved alot of trouble, he knoes nobody else is gonna kill him so why not get rid of the enemy's main asset?
In the Return of The King book, when Sauron was looking to everyone, only Gandalf was imponent beyond his eyes. (only Gandalf!)
In the first book TOLKIEN wrote that Gandalf would become like the dark lord himself if he take the ring, so, logicaly, Gandalf is powerfull enough to Defeat Sauron if he dont wear the ring, and Gandalf would certainly defeat him after he became white, because Tolkien wrote in his book ( you just have to read it) that no power on earth could hurt him, and that leads to Gandalf x witch king, the "powerfull" witch king could never, ever have hurted him like he did on the movie! This is the same Gandalf who couldn't fight a pack of wolves in the hobbit? Oh yeah and if Gandalf took the ring he would become a super-fly white guy yeah, but it would **** him up big style, he cant control the ring only Sauron can. Sauron and Gandalf are pretty evenly matched in my book but i give the fight to Sauron. The withking would totally maul Gandalf also
Oh and there is one more thing, Gandalf is a Maiar for Cryst Sake, there is no way the witch king is more powerful then Gandalf, he was only a man before, and Gandalf was an acient spirit, older then the earth, more powerfull them all other races (especialy dark spirits corrupted by Sauron) just the Valars where more powerfull them the maiars! Cryst? What God do you worship? If Gandalf if stronger than dark corrupted spirits then why did he basically have to kill himself to defeat the Balrog? If he could Kill the Witchking so easilly why doesnt he confront him? Your point about Wiki, being only a man before is true, but he is much more now. Gandalf hasn't conquered kingdoms like Wiki has, Wiki deserves his reputation.
To finish this I want to say that you guys that think the witch king is more powerful than Gandalf (hehe)...go to hell and stay there forever, you are not real fans of TLOTR and dont have to put your opinions about something you have saw in a movie. Think with me guys: Wich King can defeat Gandalf, but Gandalf is a Maiar, Sauron is a Maiar as well, Hmm...
s!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
so witch king is strong enouth to destroy Sauron? Hmm... I DONT THINK SO!!!!! You guys are nutts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Maybe so but at least i can spell 'nuts' Put it this way mate, i am a real fan of LotR and i believe the Withking would not only defeat gandalf, but just to rip off The Rock he would.....Take him to jabroni drive, to the smackdown hotel and LAYETH THE SMACKADOWN ALL OVER HIS CANDY ASS. Wiki could defeat gandalf, a maiar. Things like that can happen you know. WHat about Luthien, the lil elf lady who knocked Morgoth out? Or perhaps Fingolfin who totally gave Morgoth a good fight? Two elves can fight and nearly beat a Valar but a supremely evil, powerful and admitedly (by a powerful elf warrior himself) undefeatable being cant beat a maiar? *cough* I DONT THINK SO!!!!!!!! you are nut[b]TGo to hell and stay there 😉 Biatch [/B]