Master Sipha Dias Is Qui Gon!!

Jedi are few. Enemies are many. Need help.

Just for the record, Qui-Gon didn't disappear when he died because he was the one that came up with the ability to do that, to become one with the Force but still be able to communicate with those that haven't.

If you remember at the end of Episode III in Senator Organa's starship, after Obi Wan says he'll take care of Luke, Yoda tells him that he has some training for him to do. That "an old friend has learned the path to immortality. One who has returned from the Netherworld of the Force. Your old master."

For the record, Qui-Gon didn't disappear when he died because Lucas hadn't figured out what the heck he was doing.

Kwl!11 💃

Originally posted by Alliance
Jedi are few. Enemies are many. Need help.

But a dedicated ARMY to enforce it was absolutely not his kind of style. That's tantamount to wanting martial law.

It never, ever made the slightest bit of sense for QGJ to be Sifo-Dyas which is why it was such an insanely silly idea and was deservedly derided from the start.

Maybe its just me, but aren't the Jedi martial law anyway?

Err, no, they are a police force.

They always seem to try and kill. The only people I can think of them arresting are Gunray and that other Neimodian in TPM. Otherwise they just seem to chop limbs off people.

...not very police like.

correct me if im wrong, but wasnt it confirmed that quigon was not sifo dias? and if so that would render this thread pointless, yes? (im just sick of seeing it bumped...may as well bump the rest of the sifo dias threads)

Yes, Lucas stated that Sifo-Dyas was not a Jedi ever seen in the films.

We're just b*tching about how lame that is.

well, maybe you could deny a direct statement by lucas and declare that its art and thus your right to assume that he's wrong.

i got something to contribute to this debate
that A SQUID IF GO I SIN SO is an anagram of SIFO DIAS IS QUI GON

SQUID?
hmmm
problem solved

hes your man

Actually, thats a Quarren.

Which I will now shoot.

*pew*

actually that is what some of us refer to as a a SQUID HEAD
as in WALRUSMAN,HAMMERHEAD and SNAGGLETOOTH

I just shoot.

uh...alliance...i think u shot queeq

Originally posted by Alliance
They always seem to try and kill. The only people I can think of them arresting are Gunray and that other Neimodian in TPM. Otherwise they just seem to chop limbs off people.

...not very police like.

Very police like when attacked, though.

PVS- it's kinda moved onto why it was a dumb idea to ever think he was.

Originally posted by aldisyoyo
uh...alliance...i think u shot queeq

Well, get him some bacta, or let me take his rank.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Very police like when attacked, though.

PVS- it's kinda moved onto why it was a dumb idea to ever think he was.

I've never seen a police officer attempt to delimb someone.

Jedi attack even when not under fire.

Originally posted by Alliance
Well, get him some bacta, or let me take his rank.

Power hungry again, Alliance?

Originally posted by Alliance
I've never seen a police officer attempt to delimb someone.

Jedi attack even when not under fire.

I see you don't live in the USA. 😉

Originally posted by Alliance
Well, get him some bacta, or let me take his rank.

I've never seen a police officer attempt to delimb someone.

Jedi attack even when not under fire.

Police men don't use lightsabres. Shooting someone dead is hardly any better than hacking them with a lightsabre. But Jedi, like good police, only ever fight in appropriate circumstances and this is absolutely how it is portrayed in the films.

They are police. They are lawkeepers. Their mission is one of absolute good that they chose to do- when they could take power if they wanted- because they have an ethic of moral service to democracy.