General Grievous vs Darth Maul

Started by Emperor Revan16 pages
Originally posted by Fishy
Well he would have a lot more trouble then Obi did. Maul can not compare to Rots Obi

No, Maul can't compare with ROTS Obi but G.G. would still be like a walk in the park for Maul.

Yeah Maul could beat him

Remember Maul would be over 10 years older by rots so who know's how powerful he would have become

Maul is so good...nobody recognizes he could beat Dooku. Read "Shadow Hunter" he has been raised in the dark arts since he was a toddler. His extreme hatred for the Jedi has been planted in him by Sidious since childhood.

He was training to tbe the best warrior in the galaxy, he knew martial arts, superb sword fighting skills, lightening fast, intelligent, his only downfall is his hatred, it clouded his judgement at the end of TPM when he was toying with Obi. He beat both Qui-Gon and Obi Wan....He lost to HIMSELF

He would have chopped all Grevious's limbs off (just like Obi) in a couple seconds then destroyed him a lot faster than Obi did.

Maul was trained by fighting machines like Grevious, except three-four at a time! Oh yeah, Maul would have beat Anakin too.

Oh yeah, if Maul was only 20 years old in TPM, by ROTS he would own all the jedi.

The history of the double bladed lightsaber is interesting, it takes VERY EXCEPTIONAL skill to even attempt to use it, since too many that have tried have killed themself accidently

I think the general would have the upper hand in this one

Originally posted by Lord Neix
I think the general would have the upper hand in this one

Why? Just because?

Obi took care of Grievious without barely breaking a sweat and assuming that both Obi and Maul probably would've matured equally and considering how easily Maul took care of Obi it would've been no problem.

Grievious comes after Maul. Maul stands there, then spins, parrys, hacks off an arm or two, then spins once again taking out his legs then shoves the saber threw Grievious's forehead. Then goes "What *****!"

GRIEVOUS

Watch the Clone Wars miniseries..... You will see how BadAss GG is...

grievous would take down maul in 1 second. the reason obi beat grievous so easily is because mace crushed his chest, giving him coughing fits. therefore he wasnt as mobile as he once was

Ya know what, yeah, if Maul had lived by the time of ROTS he'd beat GG like GG's nothing. Is that what we're going on, if Maul had lived? Of are we going on if we took Maul out of TPM and GG out of ROTS and placed them in a room who would win between that version of Maul and that version of GG? I was under the impression it was the second of the 2. And folks, I'm going with Maul but Maul wouldn't own GG. Those of you who say GG would win, it'd be so close of a battle I can see your reasoning but he wouldn't take Maul out in a second Sheesh! Maul's not all powerful. neither is GG. Neither would dominate over the other. it's be extremely close.

WEll after seeing the movie id say the maul wins
did you see how easy obi wan killed the generals lightsabers
like come on his guards did beta than him with those sticks lol

The cartoons totally exaggerate GG. He is not strong with the force his only gimmick is the 4 arms. Read my post carefully!!! Maul was raised and trained fighting 4 machines like GG at once!! Maul's speed, strength, force ability, and intelligence aided him to defeat thos machines.

Here's something else to think about, after reading all 3 prequels, it has become apparent that Sidious was using Dooku as a pawn the whole time, he wasn't as satisfied as he was with Maul, who he mentored and nurtured for almost 20 years. He saw the natural ability and power in Maul just as he did in Anakin.

He really didn't give a damn about Dooku or Post suit Vader, the most powerful and potential Sith we have seen in Star Wars movies are Vader pre-suit, Maul, and of course Sidious.

How can GG even compare?

Originally posted by TraptUnderIce
Why? Just because?

Obi took care of Grievious without barely breaking a sweat and assuming that both Obi and Maul probably would've matured equally and considering how easily Maul took care of Obi it would've been no problem.

Ok, Maul is a great sith warrior. Well trained, awesome flexibility and all that. Grievous took on five jedi and defeated them. His able to use lightsabers with his feet too. His unorthodox style of fighting was a match for even experienced jedi masters. But grievous has no force abilities neither have i seen Maul's. Obi took on a weaken yet formitable GG. Remember Clone wars, Windu used the force to crake up GG. That is why we see a coughing GG in RoTs. Clone war series in the "in-betweens" of AoTc and RoTs.

I personally think that in Ep I, Maul was slightly misrepresented.

Take Darth Vasallo's well stated input as to Maul's ability: He is a PHENOMENAL sith (err... WAS). The problem with everyone's skewed view of Maul is that he was the "hafta die" villain in EP I. Just watch his death scene: Maul's saber was DOWN for almost four seconds, after NON STOP dual saber rocking against Qui Gon. Someone had to win, and it was OBVIOUSLY not going to be Maul. SO, he just "HADTA DIE"... (ya like how I swung that tangent back around to the main point? yeah, me too)
Grievous went down like Glass Joe from Punch-Out in Ep III... after first running like a jackass twice from Obi Wan. Of course, Grievous also applies to my "Hafta Die" villain theory as well...
But Darth Maul kicks way more ass....

MAUL!

If Grievious so good why does he run from Obi-Wan and why would he get his arms cut off so easily if he's such a badass?

I agree, the only reason maul didn't use any force in the first place is because GL wants to make the movie interesting.
What fun would it be if maul just pushed him off the clift?

Oh come on what kind of reasoning is that? That Jedi youngling would have killed all Clone troopers in the galaxy if it wasn't for GL trying to connect the movies more with the OT...

Maul died, GL made him die so easily because thats apparently how powerful he thought Maul was.

no Fishy,

Maul had to die because he would have interfered with th rest of the Storyline. In any case, Maul would annihilate GG....as well as Dooku. If anything he was too good to continue...and the good die young.

let's put it this way, for his age he was better than any Jedi so imagine how good he would become by AOTC or ROTS.

'nuff said

Originally posted by DarthVasallo
no Fishy,

Maul had to die because he would have interfered with th rest of the Storyline. In any case, Maul would annihilate GG....as well as Dooku. If anything he was too good to continue...and the good die young.

let's put it this way, for his age he was better than any Jedi so imagine how good he would become by AOTC or ROTS.

'nuff said

Quoted for truthery.