Charlie

Originally posted by Quincy
You gotta admit, he went out the best way yet on LOST. Dramatic, Sad, flat out amazing.

so true

it was the only LOST death i cried at...it was soo sad 🙁

I just saw epi 21 today... I cried like a baby, even though he didn't die yet..
It was(is) just so sad that hes willing to sacrifice himself.
Not sure if I want to see the last two, and actually see him die, I LOVE Charlie!!!!! But I'm addicted, so I doubt I'll be able to stay away....
I don't like when good people die! Like when Boone died, I cried my eyes out!

just watched the season finale. Though it was one of the best finale's of any tv show ive seen before.Charlie's death scene made absolutely no sense to me. Desmond was returning with the diving equiptment. And there was only a small breach that was flooding the facility. They both would have had more thane nough time to suit up and swim out. The most logical thing to do would have been for charlie to grab desmond and say, " brother, we grenade went off, water flooding lets go" and they would ahev swam to the surface with no diving gear.
Furthermore, he could have just swam through the window to the surface. The window which was allowing the water to flood in was more than large enough for him to fit through. The final scene of his death is funny as shit, because it shows him floating in front of a window big enough for him to fit through lol

made no sense what so ever for him to close that door

Originally posted by Morning_Glory
i figured he shut the door to protect Desmond from the grenade blast... but of course he could of gotten out and shut the door

but Charlie had to die... Desmond was gonna keep having more and more flashes of Charlie dying, so it would have gotten old after awhile, Desmond has to have more purposes than just having flashes of charlie dying

of course, but atleast write a more believable death scene.

Originally posted by ragesRemorse
just watched the season finale. Though it was one of the best finale's of any tv show ive seen before.Charlie's death scene made absolutely no sense to me. Desmond was returning with the diving equiptment. And there was only a small breach that was flooding the facility. They both would have had more thane nough time to suit up and swim out. The most logical thing to do would have been for charlie to grab desmond and say, " brother, we grenade went off, water flooding lets go" and they would ahev swam to the surface with no diving gear.
Furthermore, he could have just swam through the window to the surface. The window which was allowing the water to flood in was more than large enough for him to fit through. The final scene of his death is funny as shit, because it shows him floating in front of a window big enough for him to fit through lol

made no sense what so ever for him to close that door

It's pretty clear Charlie could have survived that death, but obviously he didn't because he wanted to die. He saw Mikael outside with the grenade for about 10 seconds, and he realized he had to die now in order to have Claire saved. He didn't have quite enough time to think though, because if Penny doesn't know Nyomi - then Claire being saved by them may not be a good thing.